The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 6 · December 1910
216printed page
scan 26 of 50

cation of the indifference of the Committee to Jewish public opinion. A representative committee must be frank and open with its constituency. It cannot adopt a policy of secrecy without endangering its existence.

It is an opinion that the holding of secret annual meetings is unwise and destructive of the best interests of the Committee and of the Jewish people. If they are to be kept in the dark as to what the Committee has done, if they are to be denied access through their press, to knowledge of what the Committee is doing, who are the active members, who the inactive, who the sagacious members, and who the misguiders, how long will the Committee continue to be what it claims to be, a representative national Jewish organization? How can the Committee ask for public confidence when it does not respect the public's right to information of what it is doing? We are not living in Russia, where free assembly is limited and prescribed. Whatever there are of Jewish interests in this country may be safely transacted in the full light at least of Jewish publicity.

STEPHEN S. WISE.

It is difficult to understand Dr. Stephen S. Wise. Not only his latest sensational "movement," in which he has affiliated with two Christian organizations for the holding of "union" services on Sunday evenings, but his entire rabbinical career clamors for an explanation. As a rule a public man, converted to a new allegiance, feels that it is his duty to give the reasons for the faith that is in him: but Dr. Wise has walked all over the Jewish religious field, in the public view, trampled with indifference upon the traditions of all parties in Jewry and has spoken on all subjects under the sun, but never on the one subject in which his own people are interested: What is his religion? What are his views on the serious problems of Jewish life?

He has been a Zionist. There are extant flaming outbursts of eloquence in which he espoused the cause of Zion. He

has been the rabbi of an orthodox congregation, decided in its views, orthodox in its practices. He has been the conforming leader of that congregation, holding a position there without dissent. He has been the rabbi of aradical congregation, stepping into its pulpit before his orthodox pulpit had become cold after his retirement. In the radical congregation he observed none of the forms he had been observing in his orthodox congregation. When he returned to New York, his lungs filled with the invigorating ozone of the West, it seemed to his Zionist friends that he was no longer a Zionist; he never spoke in behalf of Zionism when he sought the Emanu-El pulpit. It seemed to his orthodox friends that he was no longer orthodox. Then when he started a synagogue and called it free, and denounced all New York rabbis as time-servers and cowards, it seemed that he had also broken with his radical friends. In the Free Synago- gue services similar to those of the Ethical Culture Society are held on Sunday mornings. No provision is made for Sabbaths and holidays. It has no visible symbol to identify it as a Jewish place of worship.

Now, there may be a way to reconcile this amazing progress or wandering in the desert of indecision, but we have yet to see an effort on the part of Dr. Wise to straighten this tangle.e He never speaks of his faith. He never speaks of his own belief in religious matters. It is pertinent to inquire: Does he believe in orthodoxy ; is he conservative; is he an ethical culturist: is he a liberal; is he a Zionist? And if not what does he stand for asıde from such trite notions that Richard Crocker is not a gentleman, and the hobble skirt is moral? What is the positive, defiant non-conforming free Dr. Wise?

He speaks with a great deal of ambiguity of the resocialization of religion and in many quarters he is regarded asa socialist, but 'his position as a social reformer we do not care to discuss; what interests us primarily is a confession of Dr. Wise’s faith in matters religious and national, and this we is what he owes the Jewish public.