The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 6 · December 1910
200printed page
scan 10 of 50
Facsimile · scan 10 of 50
Scan of p. 200
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Zionist orator, the. fervid exponent of a new and independent Jewish life was suddenly s’lenced on the great question effecting the Jews as a distinct people. But why, after all, should Dr. Wise be expected to be more reverend in his attitude toward the Jewish National ideal than to other Jewish principles and traditions, to Jewish laws of life, to the Jewish Sabbath and the Jewish holy.daysr He threw one idea overboard as quickly as La dAıld annthar

Having no regard for Jewish public opinion, Dr. Wise never even felt it incumbent upon him to explain his difhicult and rapid metamorphosis. He just went ahead and talked in a different strain, and that was all there was to it. He evolved a new epigram, a few fresh phrases, and soon there was a new “torah” about the “the rejuvenation of Israel,” the chief point of which was a political lecture every Friday night on the East Side. Dr. Wise left the Congregation B’nai Jeshurun, and he was no longer orthodox. He came to Portland, and he was no longer a Zionist. He returned to New York and found thar the Reform Temple was too conservative, that Jewish Nationalism was an objectionable idea. That was all there was to it. He had nothing to explain, no apologies to offer to anybody. The thing was the sermon with its oratorical flourishes, and every time there was a new vagary to propound there was a chance for new flourishes. That was the main thing, ana for the sake of the fresh oratorical flourishes and the carefully-phrased generalities, it was absolutely necessary to establisı a new religious institution.

Of course, no reasonable, intelligent, selt-respecting person could ever see the reason for the existence of the Free Synagogue. It was not really free in anything, excepting in the indulgence of its rabbi in certain vague and loose and most general criticisms and attacks which did not affect anybody in particular, and to which no one objected. Never a word was there said in the Free Synagogue about the dominating and domineering powers in Jewry which would stifle the voice of the people; which would root out the racial and national characteristics of the Jews; never a word was said about the autocratic methods of some of the Jewish philan-

thropists and charity workers; never a word was there said about self-constituted bodies who would rule Jewish life; never a word about the real abuses in our existence; never a word about the real wrongs that prevail. No one could see the reason for the Free Synagogue, but it served Dr. Wise's purpose. It gave him a forum and it attracted attention. And for some mysterious reason, which remains to be explained, eminent and respected men in our community saw fit to give him their support.

When things were getting dull, and he was. no longer attracting the attention in which he glories, he made a combination with the Church of the Divine Paternity and the Church of the Messiah for the purpose of holding union services. “What we want to do in these services,” said Dr. Wise, “is to make better Jews and better Christians.” So this so-called rabbi conceives it as part of his duty to make better Christians. Well, if he would be honest and direct, hıs course would be very clear before him. It is obviously not possible for anyone to make better Jews and better Christians at the same time and in the same place. It Judaism is not different from Christianity, ii its teachings are not superior to those of Christianity, then, of course, there is only one thing for the Jews to do. The majority of the Jews, however, believe that Judaism is a distinet creed of life, that it is self-suffieient and superior to other religions. Most of the Rabbis have held and still hold that their main function was to make better Jews and that tlie place to do it was and is the synagogue. If Dr. Wise wishes to make better Christians, why sould he drag in the fair name of the Jew and of the synagogue?

But after all, it seems useless to argue with this sensational performer or to take him to task. He has no regard for either the Jewish people or their traditions. He is not accountable to anybody. Nothing matters in his world, excepting the latest phrase. The criticism should now be directed to the men of prominence and influence in the Jewish community of New York who have regard for Jewish feelings and Jewish traditions, and have yet seen fit to associate their names with and to give their support to the Free Synagogue.