The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 5 · November 1910
161printed page
scan 9 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN

subject, and I will treat it briefly. Life’s lessons and experiences can, and do, greatly change the different traits of our original character, which thus must be looked upon not as something stable and unalterable, but as a thing rather subject to changes and easily influenced by, other people and varying circumstances. Therefore, the Jewish character may be such at one time and different at another, may be sympathetic in one country and renulsive in annther.

Mr. Simons seriously tells us that “so- <ialism can make no permanent appeal to the Jew, for it involves the abolition of private property. Respect for private ‚ownership began for the Jew with the tenth commandment and has been fostered by tke ages which have forced upon him the abnormal development of the acquisitive faculty.”

Mr. Simons need not be alarmed; socialism does not threaten private property at all, just the reverse; it will guarantee to everybody the full possession of his property, whatever shape and form it may take. Socialism will not rob any man of his field, his house, nor of his wife, or children, nor of his ass, or goat or she-goat. So far, we have not heard that anybody in Milwaukee has been dispossessed of his property or has suffered in any way from the socialist régime there.

According to its present teachers socialism demands that all means of production, distribution and transportation be owned by the people or the Government in the same way that the Post Office is owned and operated by the Government.

I do not agree with this theory and affirm that socialism can only demand that all means of transportation, such as railroads, canals, postal and telegraph establishments, telephone systems be completely owned and operated by the Government for the people, but the means of production, that is, factories, mills, etc., be only controlled by the Government, so as to insure to the manufacturer the raw or half-raw material at a fair price, and protect the "Ultimate Consumer" from the greed of the Trusts and other monopolists.

Socialism is suspected only of a threatening attitude towards private property and individuals, but capitalism, that has reached the height of its madness and

criminality here has already shown, and is showing us every day, how it treats private property and individuals who are in its way.

en et" Fa We have seen cases where the caprice or malice of one trust official has closed factories that employed thousands of men, women and children, and by one stroke ot the pen has thrown American citizens into the street. A working man’s private property is his chance to work, and when he is robbed of that chance it may be termed the aholition nf his nrivate nranertv.

Mr. Simons tells us that “socialism presumes a fixed and definite proletariat, etc. Socialism sees the only solution for this proletariat in the coming war of the classes. etc.”

Here Mr. Simons is correct, but the fault lies with Karl Marx. He made one cardinal mistake, which his followers, instead of correcting, have emphasized still more. Having observed that certain phenomena take place everywhere under certain conditions, Karl Marx concluded that these phenomena must take place everywhere and always, as if it were natural law. Because a proletariat was found to exist almost everywhere, Marx concluded that a proletariat must inevitably exist. Because he noticed that there was everywhere a conflict between Capital and Labor, he concluded that these two forces must be always on the same terms, while modern experience shows abundantly that these two “enemies” may get on together like a pair of squabs. Of course, the fact is that we always had the poor with us, but it does not follow that they must be always with us.

Mr. Simons writes: “Prof. Munsterburg points out that....the American workman is not conscious of belonging to an inferior class, et. What is true of the American, is true in still greater measure of the Jew. There is no permanent and abiding proletariat among the Jews.... But a few years lie between Hester Street and the Bronx, etc.... 'Potentially the Jew is in the ranks of capital and not of the proletariat, whatever his actual condition.”

The American workman does not join the ranks of socialists in greater numbers because he is more stupid politically and has a poorer general education, than the