The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 5 · November 1910
160printed page
scan 8 of 52
Facsimile · scan 8 of 52
Scan of p. 160
Text · transcribed from the scan

degeneracy, physical, mental and spiritual, flourish best in the soil of oppression.

L Ideals are best bred in an atmosphere pregnant with lofty sentiment, with a noble devotion to God and mankind, with an honest desire to uplift oneself and one's surroundings. The body may be enslaved, as that of the Jew in Russia, but when the spirit is free, the soil is favorable for the growth of a healthy idealism.]

Mr. Simons wonders why the Russian Jew still clings to socialism after living in a land where he may enjoy the blessings of a republican form of government.

The answer is very plain. The American republican form of government may be better than the Russian Imperial government, but it is infinitely inferior to the democratic form of government that prevailed in Israel before the advent of the Kings.

Second, because the change from Russia, where the Jew is harassed day and night, to America, which has offered him an "asylum from political prosecution and economic distress" is not so beneficial to him as people, who do not know and appreciate the true Jewish character, are apt to imagine.

This statement sounds rather strange, and I shall proceed to explain it. The Jew, the lofty idealist, who always puts the soul above the body, and the spiritual above the mere material or physical, on reaching this land of promise and opportunity (for some people, to be sure) often finds himself in the position of the fish that jumped from the frying pan into the fire.

In Russia, where more than one hundred nations, besides the dominating one, find domicile, the Jew living mostly in the North and Southwest, is looked upon as one of the superior races. If he does not know it himself, he is often reminded about it by the government, which is never tired of telling him that his superiority, mental and spiritual, is a source of great danger to the Russians and other weak nations, who must be protected from him. And the Jew, certainly, stands a head taller than his neighbors; he knows it, and they admit it. Persecuted, as in the Middle Ages, hated but seldom ridiculed, he finds in his own, often very poor, home a

haven of rest. All the world may be against him, but his own kith and kin are always with him.

How different is the picture when he reaches this country!

Almost at the threshold he is met with an appellation, the meaning of which he does not fully comprehend, but the intonation of the voice, and the sinister fire in the eye of the speaker suggests to him something dreadful, something similar to what he so often heard in the old country.

Mr. Simons is an American of the Jewish persuasion, so he cannot understand, although he may have read about, the terrible, tragedies that are being enacted every day in thousands of Jewish homes in the cities of New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, and other places in the Jewish American Pale of Settlement.

Mr. Simons has hardly seen the hundreds of Jewish fathers who curse the day of their birth, and the thousands of Jewish mothers that are literally tearing the hair out of their heads, because they have lost their most valuable possession in this world: their children who have not officially strayed from the fathers' faith, but who nevertheless laugh at their parents openly and ridicule everything these parents hold sacred, and the Jewish home, in Russia a haven of rest and a heaven on earth has degenerated in this "asylum from political persecution and economic distress" into a living hell, and this I hope, will fully explain my comparison of the Russian Jew to the fish that jumped from the frying pan into the fire.

Mr. Simons says that "socialism can make no permanent appeal to the Jew. The influence of his history, the inherited and acquired traits of his character, and his whole habit of thought are opposed to the socialistic ideal, once the cause of socialism is divorced from the cause of political liberty."

I have above fully explained why socialism does make a permanent appeal to the Jew, and here I repeat that Socialism and Judaism are like children of one father and one mother, so great is the similitude between these two doctrines, their ideals and aspirations.

As to the inherited and acquired traits of the Jewish character, this is a very large