The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 5 · November 1910
154printed page
scan 2 of 52
154
THE MACCABAEAN

If either of these grounds contained even a substratum of validity one might be disposed to admit that the attitude of the Turkish Government is justified. But no very profound investigation is necessary to see that in either case the Porte has not the least reason for anxiety. By whatever sentiment the Jews may be animated when they emigrate to the Holy Land, surely the last thought in the world they could entertain is to settle there “as representatives of the Russian nationality.” The persecution to which our people are subjected in the dominions of the Tsar is hardly likely to inspire them with a feeling of affection, and when they wander forth in quest of a land of peace and liberty it is certainly not as representatives of a nationality to which they are considered strangers even in their native country. Mr. Straus’s fresh experience of Muscovite anti-Jewish legislation ought to leave him in no doubt on this point. The Jewish emigrant from Russia, to whatever country he may go, goes without a thought of even returning, and he displays an exem- plary zeal in adapting himself to the conditions of his new home and in acquiring the rights of naturalisation. The manner in which Russian Jews who have settled in England, the United States, or British Colonies, during the last thirty years, have assumed the duties of citizenship in their adopted country and identified themselves with its national interests is one of the most striking phenomena in the history of modern Jewry. And what is true of the Russian Jew who emigrates to the West is not less true of him who migrates to the East. Nay, it is true even in a greater measure, for the Jew feels towards Palestine not as towards an adopted country but as towards the land of his fathers. And he is willing and eager to assume the the duties of Ottoman citizenship in the same way as his brethren assume the duties of British or American citizenship. It is not his fault if he is looked upon as a representative of the Russian nationality ; it is his misfortune. And if the Ottoman Government does, indeed, look upon him in this suspicious light, it possesses an easy remedy to wash him of the stain. It should follow the example of the constitutions of England and America. It should facilitate the acquisition of civic rights by

the Russian Jew, and it will secure a loyal and valuable addition to its subjects.

The second reason, according to Mr. Oscar Straus, why the Turkish Government is unfavorably disposed towards Jewish immigration is that it is anxious ‘“4o consolidate the Empire” But what possible ground can there be for fearing that immigration of Jews would imperil the consolidation of the Empire?’ The answer is to be found in the prevalence of an erroneous view which, we thought, had long ago been dispelled. The Turkish Government, says Mr. Straus, “regard Zionism as having ultimately in view 'the carving out of a separate State.” This view is inconsistent with the first allegation that Jewish immigrants settle in Palestine as “representatives of the Russian nationality.” If they are suspected of going to the Holy Land to further Russian interests they must be acguitted of any design to create a Jewish State, unless indeed they can be credited with a quixotic desire to enlarge the Tsar’s dominions in recognition of blows ıeceived. But we can afford to ignore this inconsistency, as the suspicion in regard to the second: point can be proved to be as groundless as that in regard to the first. For upon what data is the suspicion of separatist tendencies based? By what Zionist principle can it be supported? Not a single article in the Basle programme, not a single resolution of Congress can be cited in defence of such: a view. The aims of Zionism have been publicly expounded by the leaders of our movement so often and so clearly, that we are amazed to find that erroneous items should still prevail in circles which, we would have thought, would be perfectly accurately informed. In all the declarations of Zionist policy uttered in..the name of the Organization, there has been no hint of pursuing separatist tendencies, and they who are res- ponsible’ for disseminating a contrary version are guilty of misrepresenting a great and peaceful movement. The source whence these misrepresentations emanate is not quite a secret to us; we only regret that it should consist of our kith and kin who have the best opportunity, and whom it should be a sacred duty to assist in the work which they are doing their utmost to destroy. That Mr. Straus has also de-