The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 4 · October 1910
119printed page
scan 9 of 52
Facsimile · scan 9 of 52
Scan of p. 119
Text · transcribed from the scan

It formally segregated itself from all-Israel by suppressing the nationalistic content of the religious services and the festivals or refining it away to volatile meaningless symbols, thus arbitrarily misinterpreting the intrinsic idea. In theory, Reform Judaism aimed at full and complete adaptation to the situation created by the emancipation; in practice, it was a means of preparing and facilitating ultimate conversion to Christianity.

But, side by side with the baptized Jews, the creedless Jews and the Reform Jews, there was still another group, which sought to interpret the Messianic idea from a philosophic standpoint. The Rabbis who represented this group invented the famous theory of the Mission of the Jewish people. When I say that they invented it, I do them too much honor. Actually, they invented nothing. They merely took over teachings that had been promulgated by the Christian church for seventeen centuries, and boldly attempted to transpose values. What were the teachings of the Church? It taught that the Jewish people had been condemned by Providence to remain scattered over the face of the globe; that it must live in exile and degradation in order to serve everywhere as a living witness of the truth of the Bible and of its prophecies; that its sins would be expiated only at the end of time, when the Savior would reappear on earth to intercede on their behalf; and, the last of the refractory having then been converted, there would be but one shepherd and a single flock. And what is it that these heralds of the Jewish mission proclaim? They teach that the Jewish people is destined, by a decree of Providence, to remain scattered; that it must live in the Diaspora in order to serve everywhere as a living witness of the truth of the Bible and of its prophecies; that this mission will have been fulfilled only when the very last of the refractory shall have been converted to the belief in the one and only God and in universal brotherhood; when there shall be but one shepherd and one flock. You see, it is point for point the same. Terms only are changed—values by no means. Where the Church speaks of a sentence, the Rabbis mention predestination; where the other says: then will their

sin be expiated—this says: then will their mission be fulfilled, and so on.

There is an Oriental legend to the effect that a Shah of Persia, much perturbed, sent one morning for his first interpreter of dreams, and said to him: "I have had a singularly distressing dream. It seemed to me that all of my teeth fell cut at once. Interpret this wretched dream for me!" "Verily, an evil dream!" replied the interpreter in dismay. "Your highness is forewarned that you will suffer the calamity of witnessing the death of all your near ones!" "Away with this blockhead and give him fifty strokes of the bastinado," shrieked the Shah in anger. "Fetch my second interpreter of dreams." This man appeared, and the ruler related his dream. "An evil dream!" cried the clever fellow in delight. "A splendid dream, a dream of good omen. Rejoice, your highness. It is foretold you that you are to have the good fortune to outlive all your relatives!" "That is fine," declared the Shah, gratified. "My Lord Treasurer, give my faithful interpreter here fifty gold pieces."

After the same formula the Mission Rabbis transformed the exclesiastical brand of shame into a garland, without altering the Christian train of thought. With the aid of teachings borrowed from our pitiless enemy, they robbed, or sought to rob, Judaism of its nationality, of its hopes for a future reunion, for the resumption of normal and national existence.

The sacrifice was brought. The vitalizing idea that had preserved Judaism in its integrity for almost 2,000 years was withdrawn, and disintegration ushered in. It is true that eastern Jewry was unaffected by this and remained a solid national block. But the western Jews held ostentatiously aloof and affected to use the designation of "Palestine Jew" as a term of reproach. As a reward for such tractability after a protracted period of obstinacy, they expected the Christian world to forget all of its ancient prejudices and to take them to its heart as comrades and brethren. For one short generation, (about the third quarter of the nineteenth century), this ideal seemed to be realized. During a few halcyon years from, say, 1860 to 1875, there apparently existed no Jewish problem in western Europe. Where