The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 4 · October 1910
118printed page
scan 8 of 52
118
THE MACCABAEAN

ed any such interpretation of their civil rights. They agreed in all finality to accept France as their home from thenceforward to eternity and to permit no wish or hope to flutter beyond its confines; they agreed to declare themselves Frenchmen, and nothing but Frenchmen. Notwithstanding all of this, they continued in their prayers—to yearn and to pray for the advent of the Messiah, who, if he fulfilled his mission, would lead them away from France to Palestine, where they might no longer be Frenchmen, and where, at most, they could be only French colonists. This anomaly was not at all evident to them. At any rate, they were apparently insensible to the discord.

In the course of the nineteenth century the example of France was followed by every other civilized country; here sooner, there later, until finally all of Europe and America, Russia and Romania alone excepted, had granted the Jew a fatherland. Legislators everywhere made this concession, on the tacit or expressed presumption that this fatherland must be accepted wholeheartedly, for good and all. There would be no toleration of centrifugal endeavors or fantasies. The masses are ever thoughtless. This is as true of us Jews as it is of other communities. The masses did not realize the force of this stipulation. They were happy to feel terra firma under foot after eighteen centuries of an existence comparable only to the aimless drifting of the Flying Dutchman's ghostly craft and were quite overcome by the charms of the new situation. From long habit they retained their festivals, all-pervaded as those were with the national Jewish tone and suggestions of the ancient Palestinian home, celebrating them perfunctorily without so much as troubling about their significance. These folk quietly continued to pray for the return to Jerusalem, not at all disturbed by their illogical attitude, for they came to offer up their prayers, when at all, ever more rarely; and as they gradually attained to a soothing ignorance of the original Hebrew, they could not well be disconcerted by the content of their prayers.

The minority, highly cultured and morally sensitive, could not thus easily overcome these obstacles. They wanted to have a clearly defined attitude toward the

world and life. They sought to be honest with themselves, striving for spiritual integrity, for a philosophy of the head and of the heart that would meet the demands of logic and obviate the tragic conflict of ideals. These Jews found varying solutions of a problem, whose gravity they fully appreciated. The most radical or the most sanguine chose the simplest means; they had themselves baptized. With the Messiah they yielded up their Judaism as well. For them, there existed no further discords. Tens of thousands of Jews, among them many intellectual lights, went this way during the course of the nineteenth century in the lands of emancipation, adopting a line of conduct which their fathers avoided by pursuing the thorny paths of an ever fresh exile or by ascending the stake. Others, again, disdaining baptism as self-deception and dishonesty toward their Christian fellow-citizens professed a sort of indefferentism, in which there was no room for mystic scruples of conscience. These, too, were doubtless lost to Judaism, even though they did not formally renounce it and were content to declare themselves creedless when the law of the land permitted. They far exceeded the baptized Jews in numbers, and were so numerous that the cynics could say: "Judaism nowadays is a religious community of atheists." They hoped that the new enlightenment would make such great progress among the Christians that they would pass unnoticed in the multitude of freethinkers, from whose midst all racial differences would have vanished. A third group favored neither baptism nor creedlessness, and contented themselves with an unheroic and unesthetic opportunism. These Jews graciously condescended to remain Jews, but harmonized their Judaism with a disavowal of all Messianic hopes, in that they "reformed" it; that is, they substituted for its venerable Oriental costume a fashionably trimmed coat of jaunty cut. They converted the synagogue into a church without a cross and called it a temple. They banished the, to them, incomprehensible Hebrew from the Prayer Book, and struck from the prayers every suggestion of the Messiah and of a future return to the ancient home. Reform Judaism broke consciously with historic Judaism.