The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 4 · October 1910
112printed page
scan 2 of 52
112
THE MACCABAEAN

persistently to provide for the physical wants of the citizens. Only after we have removed the despotism of physical needs can we succeed in building a higher self, a better and nobler type of man.

In our own days, it was a scientist, and not a scholastic philosopher, who advanced a theory analogous to the above. Professor Patten (of the University of Pennsylvania) announced as the mandate of science, that true freedom is incompatible with extreme poverty. To him the most hopeful sign of civilization is the fact that we have a greater amount of capital, a larger surplus with which to satisfy our physical needs, than former ages. Civilization and progress are the superstructures resting on the foundation of this economic surplus. The beauties of art and the wonders of science are possible because we are freed, to some extent, from the deadening power of physical needs. In accordance with this logical proposition, the aim of society should ever be to increase the economic surplus and to endeavor to relieve the individual citizen, insofar as possible, from a tyranny of physical want. In the province of art, religion, morals and taste the State should give the individual all freedom; but, at the same time, in order to promote this freedom and make of it more than a mere hollow phrase, it must be the main function of the government to increase the economic surplus in the nation and to secure the independence of the citizen from the material need of existence. Socialism and “Laissez-faire” must be judged solely from the point of view of utility. That economic system is just, equitable and desirable which will enable the nation to realize a larger economic surplus, so distributed as to open larger opportunities for the fulfillment of the higher desires and motives—as art, morals, etc.—in the life of the individual.

This brings us directly to the question of state interference—the most difficult problem of constitutional law, the question that continually vexes the mind of the political philosopher. It is the supreme problem in political science. The question how far the state ought to interfere with the conduct of the individual citizen, how far it should limit the scope of his interests, has ever been a most important problem. But with the opening of the indus-

trial revolution in the latter half of the Eighteenth Century, it has become also the most complicated political and social problem of modern times. Throughout the Nineteenth Century, the theory of "Laissez-faire" struggled with the Socialist ideal of a minutely regulated commonwealth, and in the first decade of the Twentieth Century such questions as Railroad Rate Regulation, the Conservation of Natural Resources and the proper control of Public Utilities show that questions of state interference are uppermost in the minds of men.

Indeed, the history of the last century and a half shows repeated efforts made in decade after decade to define the scope of state interference. Each age endeavors to settle this question according to its own light, only to find it reversed in the succeeding years. For, state interference must ever remain a problem for each generation to solve anew, guided by its own light under the peculiar conditions of the times. There is no charmed circle around individual rights which may not be crossed by state interfernce. Liberty is not a static term but a dynamic concept—"A path of progress." Individual liberty is not a negative term but a positive power, and the state may do much to enchance that power by enlarging opportunities and removing the burdens from the less fortunate in the struggle for existence.

In any existing society it is next to impossible to determine impartially the question of state interference. Is any particular extension of government endeavor in the United States beneficial to the people and conducive to true individual liberty? The moment the question is put we have the diverse answers not only of unprejudiced scientists, but also the insidious attempts to befog the issue on the part of certain classes (commonly called the "special interests"). In any discussion of the tariff question in the United States or the Lloyd-George Budget in England, there are men—powerful money kings—whose interests will be directly affected by the decision. Naturally, strong pressure is brought to bear and the victory of reform is usually but a compromise. A complete program of social reform, affecting the amelioration of the condition