The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 4 · October 1910
131printed page
scan 21 of 52
Facsimile · scan 21 of 52
Scan of p. 131
Text · transcribed from the scan

cepting this theory, we observe how, by a curious atavism, the swine and the oyster have again become the patron deities of modern Jewry. The account of Dr. Paton is made more piquant also by the occasional introduction of modern details, as for example (page 66-7):

“In order to impress the people and to recall them to their allegiance to Yahweh, the sons of the prophets went about the land in companies with music and song, appealing to the emotions of the common people, much after the manner of a modern revivalist. Saul owed his enthusiasm for Yahweh to the fact that he ‘got religion’ at one of these pronhetie meetins«.

The final recommendation of Dr. Paton's volume must be that there is in it no trace of that peculiar form of anti-Semitism which uses the higher criticism as its weapon.

MAX J. HERZBERG.

A RECORD OF JEWISH ACHIEVEMENT

THE merry war of the pro-Semites and the anti-Semites goes on. One year a book appears to prove that all the famous Jews of history were really, if one comes to investigate, Aryans, and that only the common or old clo’es variety of Jews are genuine Jews, and not much good at that. Then, next year, another volume sees the light, and herein it is conclusively set forth that all the famous men on record “have had Jewish blood in them”—in fact, all Jews are geniuses and constitute the aristocracy of the earth. Dr. Mendel Silber, the well-known rabbi of St. Louis, now publishes a sensible little encyclopedia, in twenty divisions, of the accomplishment of the Jew in various fields. He considers him in many aspects—as agriculturist, as statesman, as artist, as scientist, a writer, as warrior, as financier, as philanthropist, as traveler, as chess-player. The only volume in English hitherto existent at all similar to this has been Madison Peter’s mawkish book entitled “Justice to the Jew”—the work of a self-appointed and perpetual attorney for the Jews. Dr. Peter’s compilation is rather

*Jewish Achievement, Mendel Silber, pp. 122. Modern View Pub Co., St. Louis.

interestingly written but is deliberately intended, from all appearances, to pander to that silly mania of the Jew for claiming relationship with every famous man in history, even though he was a renegade to the Jewish faith and the Jewish nation. What satisfaction, for example, there can be in holding up Meyerbeer to admiration as a member of the mischpocha I do not understand. Meyerbeer was a despicable snob, who was afraid to call a great work of his Moses, lest it be thought too Jewish. Dr. Silber does not gush over the imposing array of names he marshals. His mood, while popular, is sufficiently scientific to avoid any appearance of an unhealthy sentimentality. From this standpoint a work like “Jewish Achievement” is very interesting. His catalogue of notabilities—some of whom have never been mentioned elsewhere in such compilations—offers a wonderful field to the student interested in the only proper study of mankind, in man. No satisfactory investigation has ever been made of the remarkable fecundity of the Jews in every kind of talent. The hitosrian of thefuture will conclude, probably, on the one hand, that the great exercises of the mental faculties exposed the Jews to abnormalities in body and soul; and, on the other hand, that persecutions and fear were excellent exciters of “temperament.” Meanwhile, careful collections of facts are valuable from any point of view.

Dr. Silber's method is clear and simple. He weaves his names into a web of easy historical and explanatory narrative. If any suggestions were to be made it would be to the effect that fewer names and more narrative should have been employed. Dr. Silber has been exhaustive sometimes, at the expense of interest. But on the whole, he presents attractively a myriad of facts, some old, many new. Here and there omissions are to be noted This is a JSON object that follows the schema. It has the following properties: choice, correct_text, confident. The value of choice is "other". The value of correct_text is "Dr. Silber's method is clear and simple. He weaves his names into a web of easy historical and explanatory narrative. If any suggestions were to be made it would be to the effect that fewer names and more narrative should have been employed. Dr. Silber has been exhaustive sometimes, at the expense of interest. But on the whole, he presents attractively a myriad of facts, some old, many new. Here and there omissions are to be noted —Metchnikoff among the biologists, Mendeleeff—hero of that most astounding achievement of the human mind, the discovery of the periodic law in chemistry, Heilprin in geology, Jacoby in medicine, Amy Levy in poetry. And surely Emma Lazarus should have been stressed more. But these are, after all, only individual differences of opinion—each of us would compile such a collection in his own way.". The value of confident is true.