Gaul and the Lombards in Upper Italy were soon no strangers in the lands to which they gave their names; similarly, the Normans were at home in England, the Magyars in Hungary and the Ottomans in Byzantium. But the Jews ever remained aliens; for they never came as invaders, nor did they quietly and unobtrusively insinuate themselves into a land. Their immigration was in the nature of a vain flight from an inevitable fate. Their advent was a memorable occurrence, mystically interwoven with religion, and kept fresh in the public mind by the clergy. Memories of the origin of every other branch and section of a people were speedily obscured in an historical twilight; in the case of the Jews, and in their case only, this could not come to pass. The Bible kept these things fresh in the memory of the nations.
A second cause of the necessarily persistent attitude of the nations in regarding the Jews as aliens was, that they had never been formally received into their commonwealths. Throughout the middle ages and even at a much later date, the idea that a man is born with certain natural and consequently inalienable rights, was quite unknown. Each individual enjoyed such rights as were conferred upon him in definite legal form and no others. The source of all right was might, the sword. The sovereign, and he alone, drew about each of his subjects the circle of prescribed rights within which he must live, move and have his being. The ruler could delegate this authority to others; but in the final event, all rights reverted back to him and had to be secured from his hand, by fear or favor. Every right acquired had to be guaranteed by means of documents and seals; if a concession could not be backed up with documentary legal evidence, it was void. All rights accorded to guilds, crafts, professions, corporations and societies had to be substantiated by formal charters; the possession of which did not, indeed, relieve the beneficiaries of the necessity of defending them with the mailed fists at any and sundry times. Whoever was not secured by a parchment had no rights, went scot-free. But this exclusion from the society established on such documentary rights seemed to the medieval mind a thing monstrous
beyond comprehension. For instance, travellers who came from distant and unknown parts to transact business, having no legal standing, were accorded a traditional courtesy that was, in its way, a parody of the law of the land. Beggars and jugglers built up guilds modelled on the honorable crafts of resident artizan burghers; buffoons and pickpockets had their leaders or "kings," who were actually recognized by the authorities; and we even know from medieval records of the Abbatessa mulierum levium, "The Abbess of the Wantons." The Jews alone stood without this compact social order, into which all other residents were so snugly fitted. For them alone there was no niche in the structure of the commonwealth. They shared neither in the privileges of a class nor the freedom of a city. No guild would admit them. They could invoke in their behalf nothing in the nature of a concession. Such documents as were drafted concerning them, not only conceded them no privileges, but explicitly deprived them of rights common to all others. At the most, they secured letters of protection for a stipulated period, though there were really revocable at will and were often thoughtlessly disregarded. The Jews were tolerated as long as their presence seemed useful or necessary, and were driven forth the moment there was no apparent need of their services. This outlawry ineradically stamped the Jews as aliens in medieval eyes, and prevented the rise of any conception of homogeneity of the Jews and their Christian neighbors.
The third and paramount cause, however, of this unalterable notion that they were aliens, was the difference in religion. Religion at this period was the one spiritual bond between the nations, and they knew of no homogeneity save that produced by a common religion. The conception of humanity and the brotherhood of man, to which the noblest of the Greeks and the great prophets of Israel had attained, was lost to the feudal world.
Love of country and national consciousness were to be awakened at a later time. Here and there a few select spirits worked their way toward a certain toleration of those holding differing faiths, a toleration, however, strongly alloyed with compassionate contempt. Nevertheless, the