The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 3 · September 1910
103printed page
scan 39 of 60
Facsimile · scan 39 of 60
Scan of p. 103
Text · transcribed from the scan

If the Jewish people has in the past given to the world what the best judges call the highest; if men like Professor Schmidt find imperfections with even the highest thus far attained, and if there is room for improvement; what is more natural than to look for this from Judaism and a Jewish state in the place where the best has been produced?

But it may be urged that there is nothing to prevent Judaism from making its contribution in the various nations where it is localized. Yes, they may, but they do not do so, for their achievements are no longer Jewish. Is Spinoza's philosophy Jewish? Is Marx' and and Lassale's socialism Jewish? No. You will say it is universal, just as Hebrew prophecy. And you are right, but there is this difference: the contributions of the prophets is recognized as specifically Hebrew (or Jewish), but Spinoza's philosophy and socialism, are not, for they are not the product of Jewish conditions—in fact are the product of non-Jewish conditions, although the solution of the problems are Jewish with the characteristic qualities of justice.

The real aim of Zionism —its greatest motive—is a possible and probable contribution to the ethical and spiritual advance of the world, which Jews have a right to make specifically and completely Jewish. What forms that advance will take, what channels it will follow, we cannot predict. A new and universal religion is not an impossibility from the race from which three of the greatest have already come. But for anything to be specifically Jewish it must come from a Jewish nation and consciousness. At any rate it is not proposed by Zionists to establish the old form of religion in which at one time sacrifice played perhaps an important part.

In fact Zionism does not carry any religious program. While it is not irreligious, it is not a non-religious movement. It was indicated above that even atheists can be Zionists. The movement is a political and cultural one. While toiling

to secure a legally assured home in Palestine, however, Zionists are doing muchmore. This object may never be realized,and all Jews will never and should nevergo there only those who find it to theiradvantage, or desire to, should do this.Zionists are benefiting Jews everywhere bytrying to arouse a Jewish national spirit.They cultivate a legitimate pride in theirrace and achievement, toward which alltoo many Jews are indifferent. If Americans of German, Irish, French, Greek,Italian, and other descent and parentage,or even naturalized Americans from therespective countries, may take legitimatepride in their ancestors and their landsand achievements, surely the Jews has anequal right and duty, wherever he may be.

. This one aim alone, which flows directly from the purpose of refounding a state, would be of intestimable benefit to Jews, if accomplished. Instead of concealment of being known as Jews, they would be proud to be of the race, and the world would respect them for this.

The value of the respect of one's fellowman is too well known to need comment. Merely by teaching the Jew to know and respect himself because of the achievements of his nation and race Zionism will accomplish enough to be worthy of the highest encouragement, for many a person nearly lost to all moral influences have been won back to Judaism and a better life thereby.

Suppose, therefore, Zionism finds it ultimately impossible to found a Jewish state in Palestine or even elsewhere, yet a movement that wins men back to Judaism, to their race and nation and to influence for good, must be a vital one. In fact, Zionism is the most important and vital movement to all Judaism for what it has done and what it will do for the cause. The unity of purpose and better understanding of Jews by themselves, which are much needed at this time and in those places where freedom is resulting in apostacy and worse, these are ideas that will be productive of the highest good and greatest progress.