with the most serious consequences, if it could ever be compensated for.
And last, and most important of all, suppose the Jews had the country, Professor Schmidt fails to see what service it would be to Jews and to the world at large that the Jewish state be re-established, the temple rebuilt and the daily sacrifices again offered at Jerusalem. This would add nothing to the lofty achievements of Judaism in the past or whatever Judaism might add in the Dispersion.
Professor Schmidt is right. The mere establishment of the old state and the old form of worship would add nothing. But this proves Prof. Schmidt must be ignorant of the aims and possibilities of Zionism.
So much is certain with regard to Zionism: while it aims to secure Palestine as a land for the Jewish nation and while the exceeding, but not insurmountable. dificulty of this is granted, Zionism nowhere and at no time—so far as I know or have ever learned after six years of close study of and earnest effort to understand and help the movement—had as its object the re-establishment of the old religion of sacrifice This aim which Professor Schmidt propounded as perhaps the highest possible one, is positively foreign to Zionism. There are many Zionists, and enthusiastic ones at that, who are indifferent to religion or worship, who are either agnostics or atheists. There are many reformed Jews who discountenance Jewish prayer—which, by the way, Dr. Schmidt referred to as .of the finest, if not absolutely so, and there are Jews orthodox in tendency and practice, who are Zionists. There are even Christians Zjonists. Does kny body suppose that these various kinds of men would adhere to and labor for:a movement that has for its supreme object the rebuilding of the temple and the offering there of the old animal and other sacrifices?
If Zionism is not, or has not for its aim, what Professor Schmidt has stated it to be, what is it? I may be permitted to present some ideas on this subject as far as concerns a purpose for which Palestine should become again the land of the Jews. The details of future development are not worked out or even formulated. Of the possibilities and uses of the Jewish state, each individual may form his
own ideas. Only its existence can tell. But any ideas as to what Zionism and a Jewish race and nation may accomplish and should, provided that they do not controvert the fundamental purposes, are admissible. Whether the movement is desirable and should be encouraged depends on what we conceive its purposes to be.
The official program of Zionists is the securing of Palestine, the ancient land of the Jews, as a legally and publicly assured home. The reasons for the desirability of this are manifold, for the Jew and perhaps also for non-Jew alike. First and foremost it would serve as a Jewish center for the protection of Jews, which to the disgrace of civilization they still need.
But aside from all material, economic, and civil advantages and supposing the object, in spite of great difficulties, attained, what, let us question, could be gained from the point of view of moral progress of the nation and world, by the establishment of a Jewish state or the attempt to do this? The Hebrew prophets have already given their nation and the world the very highest ideals of justice and of ethics.
The teachings of Jesus, a Jew, have been given to the world. Since Jesus, practically every idea and influence in the civilized world tending toward justice, humanity, and enlightenment has come from Jews or been due to Judaism. Proof lies in the work of Mohammed, Spinoza, Mendelssohn, Marx and Lassalle. These forces, however, can continue in the dispersion. What is left for a nation?
Surely not to rebuild the temple and re-establish sacrifice. As a matter of fact nobody can say what really would result. When the western hemisphere was found in the era of land discoveries, who knew that a wonderful United States would result? When a Rockefeller founds an institution for medical research, who knows whether a spinal meningitis antitoxin will result? When research is provided for by a Carnegie Institute and promoted by every real university, who knows what will result? But who will say that, because we do not know and perhaps cannot see the result, no attempt should be made to secure results. All advance and progress has come from the attempt to do and to discover.