The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 3 · September 1910
101printed page
scan 37 of 60
THE MACCABAEAN
101

A CRITICISM OF CERTAIN VIEWS ON ZIONISMHELD BY PROF. SCHMIDT

In a public lecture on the Ethics of Judaism, delivered on the evening of July ıoth at Madison, Wis., under the auspices of the school of the Society of Ethical Culture and—to a certain extent at least—of the Summer session of the University of Wisconsin, Professor Nathaniel Schmidt of Cornell University took occasion to refer to Zionism as a means of perpetuat- ine Tudaism.

The lecture in general need not be discussed here. Suffice it to say that it was almost completely a panegyric on Judaism, and the lecturer made clear that the Ethics of Judaism as a religion have never been improved upon and probably never can be. The latter, however, was stated only by implication when the lecturer said that Judaism is pre-eminently the religion of justice, has maintained itself thus far against all destruction, particularly against Christianity, and he hoped it always would. This was strengthened when the lecturer said he was sure it would, for no Jew can believe in the divinity or superhuman or non-human character of Jesus, the man of Nazareth. The purpose and logic of the lecture was clear and convincing.

It was Professor Schmidt’s reference to Zionism which calls for a protest and was the occasion of the presentation of the ideas here expressed. Apparently he has failed to understand and interpret aright the purpose of Zionism as many others have done even among Jews themselves. Certainly he gave an entirely wrong idea of the purpose of Zionism.

The lecturer was right in saying that Zionists hope to get Palestine as the country of the Jews again; but the purpose in doing this which he attributed to them was, I believe, entirely erroneous. Professor Schmidt was referring to the forces at work tending to disintegrate Judaism and spoke of equal rights and freedom among them. Judaism survived opposition

but favorable conditions often cause atrophy. He referred to the case of a German rabbi who visited Sweden and on his return home said that Judaism was in a sad condition in the northern country—because anti-Semitism was unknown there. Now Zionism aims to keep alive Judaism. How is it fitted to do this? Prof. Schmidt would ask.

Simply to found a state in Palestine would have little effect if no new vital principle were introduced. The old order of things in the restored land would help nothing. Professor Schmidt said that Judaism has never believed in a blood sacrifice —a human sacrifice—to atone for the sins of mankind, which is the very foundation and superstructure of Christianity. He went on to say that Judaism had long since emancipated itself from all sacrifice of man or animal and had learned to exist and would continue to exist by its moral force alone, even though Jews are no longer a nation. What, then, of the Zionist plan for a new Jewish state reared on its old soil, a nation in and about Jerusalem—a state whither the nations of the world might look for peace and ideals of justice?

What has such a state to offer and how would it benefit Judaism? How would it improve the influence of Judaism on the world? What difference does it make if the nations look for peace to the Hague or to Jerusalem? Not at all, Professor Schmidt answers. Suppose Jews could somehow get Palestine and Jerusalem, there would be endless trouble, dispute, fighting —yes, bloodshed!—in the contest for the sacred places of Jew, Christian, and Mohammedan.

Next, how would the Jews get rid of the Turks and Arabs, not to mention nationalities, in the land, from an economic point of view. This dispossession, whether peaceful or forceable, would be fraught