The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 3 · September 1910
95printed page
scan 23 of 60
THE MACCABAEAN
95

Some people say that there is no problem to solve, but I am not of them. To me there is a very definite problem. I do not hold the view that an alien race in a small minority scattered among the European nations can maintain its position without friction. The experience of our own generation is sufficient to disprove that. It seems to me that the problem will always arise, and we can be certain a priori of that, even if we had not a concrete instance, such as the Dreyfus case, before us, because the interests of the two races, their ideals, their psychology, are different."

Since there is a problem, then what is the solution?

"What is the solution if one is demanded? How can we minimise the friction? By what machinery can we arrange that no injustice shall be done to the alien race—the small minority in our midst? That is the problem. Of course there are some Jews—especially the very wealthy—who pretend that there is no problem. They shut their eyes—deliberately or unconsciously—to its existence. But they are wrong. The Jewish problem exists definitely for every one of the Jewish race in Europe."

I suppose the creation of a Jewish State, of a Jewish centre outside of the European nations, is the solution?

"That of course, is the view of the Jewish patriot—of the type of Zangwill—but I do not care to express a view on it.

Only a Jew is qualified to do so. Yet without hesitation I must say that, little qualified as I am to judge, the scheme of a Jewish State seems to me to be quite impracticable. The Jew is too much a part of Europe ever to be satisfied and successful apart from Europe. Moreover the very Jews who are most firmly fixed among the other nations are chief causes of the problem. So long as there are great conglom- erations of Jews in ancient surronndigs,, the Jewish problem will persist. If the Jews‘ would be absorbed as the Hugenots, for instance, have been ‘absorbed by the pepole’s among whom they took refuge, the problem would in course of time solve itself. But this they cannot and will not do, and if I were a Jew, I should ecrtainly not desire the absorption of my race. The Jew never sinks himself in his English or French or German surroundings. He is always possessed—consciously or unconsciously—of his Jewishness and this is as true of the man of almost remote Jewish descent as it is of the regular syna- gooue attendant. He cannot get away from his ancestry and this makes him quite different from his neighbors.”

The article on Theodor Herzl, written by Martin Buber, which appeared in the August MACCABAEAN, was taken from the German original that appeared in the Herzl number of Die Wclt.