doctrine, still unemancipated from a judgment of others based on the contents of their mind. I then formulated the matter—as I still believe, rightly,—thus: "Herzl had no cognition of the fact that the real Jewish question is a spiritual and individual one, that is, the attitude of every individual Jew toward the peculiar comity into which he was born, of which he finds himself to be a part, and towards his Jewishness of nature; and that this alone constitutes the nation. This Herzl denied. Therefore he neglected, in the Judenstaat and in all his later writings, to consider the problem of the peculiarly Jewish and how that might be fostered, one of the most remarkable of all culture-problems." I repeat that this analysis still seems correct to me. But beyond it, and untouched by it, the essential appears.
The essential I regard as this—that in this circumscribed greatness of Herzl rested—for us and for all Jews—his typical, model greatness. This criterion, as represented by him, must forever remain unapproachable for the rest of us, because his greatness is naive, primal, elemental. Like all greatness it is the product of a lack—an elemental lack, which we have not—we theorists with our problems.
Whence comes our recognizance that the real Jewish question is one of the spirit? It comes to us because our Judaism with us is a problem,—because our subjectivity with us is a problem,—because our very existence with us is a problem.
This is the great, tragic Jewish heritage: problem propounding, the Golus form of the spiritual division.
Spiritual division! Out of the longing to be saved, out of this spiritual division, all the great Jewish unities have come to be. But the Golus Jew, too weak to create new unities, becomes a mere propounder of problems.
The subjectivity of him whose activity is elemental, of the Doer, is given to him as an abundance of impulses, of which he becomes conscious only in order that he may bring them to fruition. His existence is given him as a fullness of reality, transforming him, and at the same time impatiently awaiting its transformation by him.
To the propounder of problems his subjectivity is given as a plenitude of questionings, demanding an answer from him, which can arrive at an ultimate solution only in the absolute and never in the particular. His existence is given him as a sheaf of contradictions, permitting his ultimate solution of them only in the metaphysical and never in the practical sense.
In the Doer his impulse to do is so great that it hinders his theorizing.
In the Theorist the impulse to spin theories is so strong that it prevents him from doing.
The Doer becomes suddenly aroused to his Jewishness. There at once awakes within him the will to help all Jews, of whom he now knows himself to be one; to bring them out of the abnormal condition where freedom and security will be their portion. Indeed, he does that which his will prompts him to do. He sees nothing else.
The Theorist becomes conscious of his Judaism; and he finds himself confronted by the colossal contradiction, by the monstrous paradox of the existence "Jewish." He sees everything—all the degeneration, all the faultiness, all the spiritual constraint. Before he can do, he must grapple with a thousand doubts.
The Doer works in broad daylight, even when he errs; the Theorist suffers in the dark, even when he comprehends.
The error of the one is sometimes more fruitful than the understanding of the other.
The typical greatness of Theodor Herzl lay in his having been a Doer, strongly and elementally active.
Typical I call it, because it imposes a duty, one of the largest duties the human soul knows: that of achieving inner unity.
For there is a way for the Theorist to surmount his problems.
To be sure, he has no approach to the naive, the primal, the elemental. These must be possessed as a birthright, they cannot be achieved.
He cannot doff his spiritual anarchy. But he can fling himself out over and above it, in that union of his spiritual forces that is capable of receiving enlightenment: the enlightenment that teaches one how to work and to achieve.
