The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 2 · August 1910
58printed page
scan 24 of 50
Facsimile · scan 24 of 50
Scan of p. 58
Text · transcribed from the scan

tee. They had not cared to secure proxy credentials, as had been done by other members of the committee. Many of those who had signed the resolution had not understood its purpose. Incidentally he criticised the annual report of the Maskir, saying that much of the good work reported had not been done. He believed that his services in connection with the formation of the order, and its subsequent growth, entitled him to a place on the executive.

On motion of Dr. Bluestone the speakers were restricted to three minutes each.

Mr. Werbelowsky stated that no ulterior motives existed. The intention of the conference had been simply to limit membership on the executive to regularly accredited delegates of the camps.

Mr. Sprayregen upon his special request, was granted five minutes. He objected to the resolution. Representative government meant government by persons. Camps alone did not and could not do entire work. Those New York members of the executive who were accredited by camps in distant cities should not be their spokesmen in fact. Mr. Sprayregen also criticised the work of the Maskir. The resolution had been inspired by malice and the support enlisted of persons unaware of its intent.

Mr. Falkoff said: "No personalities had been intended. The only aim had been to assure the stability of the order by preventing its administration from falling into the hands of non-Zionists or unfit persons. The Executive Committee should consist of persons who are known to and have confidence of the camps."

Rabbi Brodsky, whose credential had been declared void by the Credential Committee because he was not a member of any camp, declared that he was a member of the Rishon L'Zion Camp No. 24: that he had not been elected to the Executive Committee, but appointed to fill a vacancy. Had done active work on behalf of the order.

Dr. Bluestone stated that Rabbi Brod-sky's name did not appear on the membership list of the Rishon L'Zion Camp.

Mr. Sprayregen asked how he had become a member of the executive if he were not afhliated with the order.

Mr. Esserman stated that he knew Rabbi Brodsky to be a member of the Rishon L'Zion Camp. He had recommended his appointment on the Executive Committee. There must be some error in the lists.

Mr. Barondess suggested that the president of the Rishon L'Zion Camp be called upon for a statement. The secretary of the camp stated that Rabbi Brodsky was a member of his camp, and that an error had been committed by a preceding secretary of the camp.

Mr. M. Dunn, Mr. J. Dünn, Mr. Neuhauser, Mr. Finkelstein, Mr. Friedland, and Mr. Hoffman also discussed the motion.

Mr. Golin offered an amendment to Mr. Werbelowsky's motion to the effect that executive members who were not delegates be eligible as candidates for office.

Mr. Jasin stated that resolution was concerned with a principle and not with persons. Dr. Epstein and Mr. Sprayregen had chosen to make it a personal matter. Persons who neither paid dues nor answered letters from the officers of their camp were not good members. The signers of the resolution meant to weed out inactive persons and personal politics.

Mr. Sprayregen, understanding Mr. Jasin's remarks as a personal reflection, made some slighting reference to Mr. Jasin.

The amendment to extend privileges of delegates to executive members was lost on a rising vote, 46 to 40.

A vote on roll call was demanded and granted. This reversed the previous vote, and the amendment was carried by 43 to 39, with the understanding that it apply only to present convention.

The passing of the amendment .automatically killed the original motion. The Committee on President's Message report-ed through its chairman, Dr. Tarlaw, and the recommendations contained thereinwere taken up seriatim.

I.—(Adoption Recommended.)

That all communications of order and of individual camps bear National Fund stamps. Carried on motion.

II.—(Adoption recommended.)

All monies for Zionist Institutions should be transmitted by camps to the