The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 1 · July 1910
29printed page
scan 29 of 50
THE MACCABAEAN
29

through it and in some places, especially in one large eastern city, it has been a constant rivalry over its chairmanship. In that city the movement was actually paralyzed for a few years on that account. And at the best rate what has been accomplished through the councils? The most is a ball and a mass-meeting, which very often proves a total failure.

. Is there a better system of organization? ‚l believe there is. I believe that we could .have a disciplined and well organized or- „ganization by abolishing the individual so- „cieties and organizing them into United „Zionists. The advantages of this scheme ‚are numerous. First, the Federation would ‚have only one responsible body in each of „the larger cities to refer to, a body which „would consist of the most active members ‘and all her communications would thus be received first hand and not second or third “hand as the case is now.

Second, a united body of that kind is logically bound by virtue of united effort to accomplish more work. Then again the saving of time that is otherwise being lost on the numberless meetings and offices and this could be well utilized for practical work.

Third, it would do away with the so-called Kleisel selfishness! The well-known advertisements of the following description will prove my statement:

"Societies will please take notice that we, the so and so, are making preparations for a grand picnic, hall or mass-meeting, whatever the case, may be, for this and this date, etc., (usually a few months in advance.)"

Why, then, in the name of common sense couldn't that be done united and save the energy and extra expense for something else and also make a success of whatever we undertake?

Fourth, the moral prestige that could thus be gained. We Zionists have been boasting about the solidarity that exists in our ranks owing to our common ideal. While it is true in a sense, it isn't however, as great as it should have been. It is easily noticeable the somewhat cool and conservative disposition of the American-born Jews and the rather nervous temperament of the one coming from Russia or Galicia. The former possess more discipline and tact while the latter are much better posted on current Jewish topics, lit-

erature, arts, etc. By bringing them together they would prove to be of a great mutual, educational benefit to each other and thereby help to eliminate the so to say, geographical antagonism that exists among our people. The present system only encourages its existence.

These are principally the main points in favor of the proposed reorganization, though I could enumerate a few more in favor of it but the space will not allow me to do it. There also are a few objections to it but not serious ones and the former will heavily overbalance the latter. Tradition will be here one of the chief obstacles.

It is my opinion that the per capita tax should be raised to two dollars a year, for which each member should receive gratis a shekel and either THE MACCABAEAN or Dos Yiddishe Volk. The value of these papers as propaganda mediums is being sadly overlooked while there is a splendid field for making them not only independent but also paying propositions. It needs only some effort. And I don’t believe that one would experience much difficulty in collecting fifty cents quarterly.

JACOB FARBSTEIN.

The Work of the Kadimah of New York

The Benai and Benoth Kadimah of New York has issued a statement covering its last six months’ work, which gives a most interesting view of some excellent results. In spite of the withdrawal of a number of its members from active work, and with a smaller membership, the Kad- maihı contributed the following to the movement: It held three large mass meetings in synagogues, and twelve literary meetings, It sold over 410 shekolim. It dollected for the National Fund from members, $12.58; Dr. Max Nordau in the Golden Book, $50. It purchased two shares of the Zion Press Association, in addition to three purchased at a previous date, $ro. It contributed also $12 to the thousand dollar fund of Dos Yiddishe Volk, and secured twenty subscribers for that publication, and also procured advertising contracts amounting to $50. It purchased and presented to the National Fund two dunams of land, $1o. It paid dues to the Federation for fifty members, $12.50, and Council dues, $3. It also assisted a number of other Zionist societies from its treasury, as follows: Dr. Herzi Zion Club, tickets, $5.50; Echo Zion Club, tickets, $2.00. Young Folks’ League, 50 cents, and for Zionist literature, $7. This record is a remarkably good one.