The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
196printed page
scan 10 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN

conclusions, a reading of his book leaves certain clear, well-defined views.

After quoting the views of numerous writers on anti-Semitism to illustrate how large a diversity of view and apparent contradiction and inconsistency exist on the subject, the author begins his analysis. Ever since his dispersion, countless charges have been brought against the Jew. He was accused alternately of being a pauper and a capitalist, of being ignorant and extraordinarily intelligent; a reactionary and a revolutionist, his vices were described as his virtues and his virtues as his vices. All these accusations have repeatedly been proven false; it has been shown that the vices charged were no more characteristic of the Jew than of any other people. From this only one conclusion is to be drawn; that these accusations were not based on fact, but were due to a prejudice against the Jew, that this prejudice was not the effect or the result of the accusations against him, but the effect or the result of prejudice.

Once the cause of the prejudice is determined, the reason for anti-Semitism is disclosed. This, according to Mr. Schomer, is the key to the problem, and is also the reef upon which so many investigators «of the subject have foundered. Insteail «of adhering to a direct course to determine the cause of the prejudice, they wan- «dered off to explain the effect of the pre- ‚Judice. To this task the author devotes ‘himself, Prejudice, he asserts, is a feeling, an emotion created under some mental law, and since the prejudice exists in ‘the mind of the Gentile, the problem becomes a psychological one. Therefore, in the psychology of the Gentile the cause of the prejudice must be found. Since the individual Jew possesses no peculiar characteristics or deficiency to call forth a pre-judlice against him, the prejudice must be caled forth by the Jewish people m üts entirely. The author then disposes of the view that the difference in religious beliefs of the Jew and the Gentile causes the prejudice

against the Jewish people, and after arguing against certain other supposed causes for the hatred of the Jewish people, he sets forth his theory.

ee Fa There are as many as twelve million. Jews in the world. These twelve millon Jews do not constitute a: definite, normai body or association. In order to constitute this, it must possess the element ot unity in name, object and capability of assemblage and representation. Two of these elements the Jewish people possess. It has a common name and it has a common object. The Jews were organized by Moses after they left Egypt as a. distinct society, a people with the sole purpose of keeping holy and observing certain fundamental ethical laws as expressed in the Ten Commandments and in the by-laws given them by Moses to enforce the observance of the fundamental principles. Hence, the Jewish people has no other than an ethical or spiritual purpose for its existence The third element of a normal society, that of assemblage and representation, the Jewish people now lacks. Lacking this element, the Jews constitute merely a multitude, an abnormal phenomenon consisting of a plurality of elements, without unity. Here the author adduces scien- tiie data to prove that in order that the mind may properly and logically conceive an object consisting of a plurality of elements, it must be able to affirm a unity over the plurality. For example, when the mind thinks of a man, it conceives a unity, despite the fact that the man is composed of a plurality of elements, such as cells and organs. The Jewish people being composed of a plurality of Jews, and lacking the element of organization to make it a unity, “the mind can form no true conception of what the Jews are. It cannot as against the plurality afırm a unity, nor can it as against the unity affirm a plurality. The judgment here can be neither logical nor psychological. The reason for this is that in order to enable the mind to think rightiy of a collective body, the body must be a normal one. The collec-