The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
153printed page
scan 3 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
153

and it had reported that East Africa was unsuitable for us. The report was printed.

EL TE ED, ee De en Ne A Zangwill wanted to create in East Africa not a Nachtasyl but a homeland. At the same time Herzl negotiated with the ex-Sultan Abdul Hamid. Abdul Hamid offered Herzl to allow a settlement of Jews throughout Turkey. Herzl at once refused, because he said that the solution of the Jewish question could only take place in a Jewish home, a homeland, a national centre. Palestine was the only possible Jewish centre. Zangwill had the same idea, and that is why he is sending people to Galveston. Herz] was a poet— not a Jewish poet. When he arose he knew very little about Jewish matters. He studied them, wrote the new Ghetto work, a novel, in which he gives expression to the fact that the home of the Jewish people can only lie in its ancient land, and that assimilation is a misfortune for us Jews. Herzl wrote his -“Altneuland,” Zangpwill writes a “Meltinge-Pot.”

LITTLE RESEMBLANCE TO HERZL.

You will have already preceived from + these observations that Zangwill bears little resemblance to our Herzl, and that he is not “the natural successor of Dr. Herzl.” The real successor, ladies and gentlemen, is elected by Congress, not by the Ito and not by himself. Zangwill gives us a piece of advice—after declaring that everything is dead this is his last resource—he advises that the Jews should .emigrate to America, it being better, in his opinion, that they should become more American than the Americans than more Turkish than the Turks. This advice, to my mind, is superfluous and also comes much too late. Jews had emigrated to America before Zangwill saw the light. They did not wait for him to advise them to go. But there is one thing in this connection that Mr. Zangwill forgets. He forgets that among the Jewish settlers in America there are thousands and tens of thousands of Zionists who want to go to Zion. Mr. Zangwill gives us advice. I feel bound to

say—with all respect for Mr. Zangwill—that it is difficult to follow his advice on Jewish matters because he has altered his opinion so often. What at one time he found splendid, to-day he finds bad. Moreover, we cannot follow his advice because he has lost faith in the Jewish people, because he no longer believes in our future. But I should like to give him a piece of advice. I should like to tell the master of Jewish wit that he must not mix up Jewish wit with Jewish pain, must not confuse the Judenwitz and the Judenschmerz.

And now that I have done with the Chometz, let me come to ourselves. Our honored President of the Federation, Dr. Dreyfus, referred to the events at the last Congress in Hamburg. I am sorry— however hard it is for me—that I must say a few words about myself. In Hamburg, as you know, we encountered great opposition which was directed against headquarters—"headquarters” chiefly meant myself—and a whole series of accusations were brought forward, which, as you know. were refuted and answered at the Congress. But since the Congress the same sort of thing has been going on. Even now all sorts of accusations are made, partly the same as those brought forward before and partly new ones. I am now reproached with being an autocrat and with not being able to stand criticism. This is, however, untrue. On the contrary, I hold the view that criticism is absolutely necessary. Dr. Strauss said that we are a democratic movement. That is what differentiates us so advantageousiy from all other Jewish organizations. We depend on the masses. Everyone can have his say, everything can be criticised. Criticisni is necessary. But criticism must come, if it comes at all, from people who know what they are talking about. It must be intelligent criticism, and above all, it must be honest criticism. Useful criticism, honest criticism helps and assists; criticism that is not intelligent and not honest embitters and hinders. I have no objection to crit-