him, and when they could not secure a congregation to take him, they organized a new Chevra. That was the kind of friends he had! It wasn’t a Chevra large or rich, but so so. Just competent to take care of Reb Chayim. And there, with no one to suspect him of wrong-doing, no one to observe his little weaknesses, no one to misunderstand him, he led the life he loved. As for his voice, which his good friends, his colleagues, the Chazonim, were beginning to criticize, who in that congregation cared whether it was as good as it used to be? It was one of the ar ticles of faith with them! A stranger coming into that synagogue and hearing Reb Chayim on an ordinary Sabbath for the first time would say, ‘Why do they make so much fuss about their Chazan? He is only an old man with a broken voice, trying hard to remember the tunes.’ And he may have come to the conclusion that, like all old things, Reb Chayim was not what he was cracked up to be. If this stranger happened to give utterance to this heretical opinion, he would be taken at once by the scruff of the neck and turned out, for they were all more or less his old friends. The president, an old chorister; the secretary, a neighbor whose father used to give Reb Chayim lekach on holidays when he was a boy; the shammes, an old man who used to play with him; and the Baal Shacharis bragged— bragged, mind you, of it—that at one time he was in the same choir with Reb Chayim in the old country! Chayim was the boon companion of Maskilim, for he wrote good Hebrew poetry, they said. Some of us here have seen the Hebrew poetry Reb Chayim wrote. It was something unique. A Chazan who knew more Hebrew than the mere reading and singing of it, and who, in spite of being a Chazan, was a man for all that, could argue a passage in the Talmud, could tell good stories, and was not vain. He had more or less of a voice until the last. His broad little face, which fell away in old age, wore a fine mellow smile and he had
good white teeth until he died. You should have seen him walking in the street. He twirled a light cane like a young man, and you could never see him lean on it, not for the world! He was a constant visitor at the book stores, and was always ready with a quip, a joke, a good word. You may be sure that he did ride and play okey on Sabbath; you may be sure that he did take a glass too much occasionally; but in New York nobody noticed ie Who cared? He was Reb Chayim Weinschel, a fine old man, thoroughly alive, a jovial companion, generous and happy. In short, Reb Chayim was thoroughiy at home in New York. There he could breathe freely. There he was a Chazan who had some special privileges. There they asked, not what sort of a pietist he was, but what sort of a man, Here you tried to suffocate him. Everything about your city is oppressive, petty, village-like; you want to know what one has for breakfast, what for dinner and what for supper. If you had only considered that you were sufhciently honored in having Reb Chayim as your Chazan, he could have remained here for some years. He liked kindly people, but you not only wanted the Chazan, you wantea also the man. This I can tell you; if your city will ever be remembered, it will be only for one thing, as the place where Reb Chayim Weinschel was not treated honorably.”
"There was a story in the newspapers," says Judel after a pause, "that he made a fine joke before he died. Was that true?"
"True, and not true. You can't believe all you read, even in your kosher newspapers. He caught cold, and was compelled to take to his bed. His old wife did all she could for him, and like all old women, was afraid of the word death, and thought by refusing to say the word, that death would be warded off. But Reb Chayim, on the contrary, while he lay in bed breathing heavily, mocked his wife, saying, now she would see what it was to
