The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
166printed page
scan 16 of 52

edge of music, but it is a tradition among Jews that every one is entitled to an opinion on Chazanuth; it is an inheritance from one's "fathers' fathers."

"He had a habit of saying: in this country it is not so easy to sing. As if that made any difference," says the Dayin, and he added: "The trouble with Reb Chayim was that he was indeed a Chazan."

"To be pious and a Chazan is impossible. I wonder why that is, why it should be," observed Yankel.

"For a very good reason," interposes the Rav, with a twinkle in his eye, pausing between strides, stroking his scanty beard. "The Chazan, as you know, is only the messenger of the congregation. Have you ever seen a messenger that had any interest in his message? In the first place, he doesn't pray for himself, and after he has prayed for others, do you suppose he will also pray for himself?"

A smile ripples over the group.

“As to his being a Chazan, there can be nothing said against that,” began the Shammes, “but there was an impudent rascal for you! To play cards on a Sabhath; on Ferry street and in a store! Have you ever heard the like?”

"Have I ever heard the like! A question!"

"He was a fine Chazan," concluded Yankel, "why, look here. I remember the first Friday he sang for us. I'll never forget it. When he made a Lecho Dodi, and turned around and repeated the refrain and smiled and showed his beautiful white teeth; that was a beautiful sight! I never felt the beauty of the Sabbath so much, never appreciated the poetry of the prayers, until Reb Chayim sang that song..."

Judel, the house-painter, then inquires whether, in Yankel's opinion, it is true that James G. Blaine has been attacked by the A.P.A.'s; and music, as if dreading the commonplace, takes to cover.

"Ah," says Yankel, rubbing his hands. He hastens to reply, for he is proud of being a politician. "Sometimes it is bad politics to be a Catholic; but it is worse

politics, not to be a Catholic, and to attack them. You see, they are not like us Jews, satisfied with what they get; a blow, all right; a little flattery, all right too! If you attack them, they have long memories; they remember, 'Ei, and how long! Some day they pay back all that's coming to you. It's bad politics to go for them! Bad politics!"

Judel repeats his question: "But did they do it?"

"Of course they did it. If the A.P.A.'s even smell that one is a friend of the Catholics, they 'knife' him. And the worst of it is, Blaine has either a brother or an uncle who is a real Catholic. He won't be elected, I'm afraid."

Yankel is a Republican.

"And for my part," says Judel indignantly, "Let the A.P.A.'s go for him. What? The Catholics already run the city. You know what's going on, Yankel; you belong to the machine; then tell me. Why did they appoint Reilly if not because Father Jerome is his friend? There ought to be some one to give it to them."

Thus they arrive at the Jesuits.

Joey becomes excited at the mere mention of Jesuits. He conjures up the wandering Jew, Father Rodin, the Inquisition. Rodin was a monster; is Father Jerome a monster too?

"What an idea," says Aleck, "there's different kinds of Jesuits. The American Jesuit can't be half as bad as the French Jesuit; the French Jesuits are frog eaters and they speak in a way no American can understand."

"You can't tell; they have a way of sneaking around," mutters Joey.

Anton Rubenstein serves as an introduction to a further analysis of Reb Chayim.

"Chayim Suwalker spoke to Rubenstein in St. Petersburg," says Yankel. "He went up to the pianist and said, in his winning way, 'Peace be with you,' and held out his hand. What do you think? Rubenstein took it and said, thank you, and then they talked for about an hour."