The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
160printed page
scan 10 of 52
Facsimile · scan 10 of 52
Scan of p. 160
Text · transcribed from the scan

ed up our knowledge of Palestine, and for many reasons. The early Chovevi Zionists, rich in good-will, but poor in organization and in means, were not in a position to devote themselves to the task. If they ever had an idea of exploring Palestine, the means, and political far-sightedness, were lacking. The Rothschild administration, working in the Holy Land, had no intention of promoting national colonization, and the one object they had in view was the liquidation of an unprofitable business. This is especially true of the policy of the Ika, which has succeeded to the Rothschild interests.

Then came political Zionism with its view of the entire Jewish question, which proclaimed the existence of the Jewish nation. It analyzed the position of the Jews in dispersion, and found that the trouble of the Jews was due to their dispersion. It proposed, therefore, a territorial concentration. The first Congress stated the object, and outlined the means for its attainment.e The international parliament of nations must be called upon to give Palestine to the Jews. The Jews themselves were not to conquer their country. It was there evident that not Palestıne was the first consideration, but what would be the attitude of the governments, from which Palestine was to be obtained. After several years of propaganda, and with no appreciable results, the policy of political Zionism was slightly altered. It was decided that a charter must first be obtained from the Turkish government, and the main objective of the Zionist executive committee became Constantinople, Then, business in Constantinople being unsatisfactory, to create the impression upon Turkey that Zionism may, under certain conditions, be able to do without Zion, and thus make the Sultan of Turkey more eager for business, El-Arish and then Uganda were found. Palestine became the theoretical goal, but not the object of the immediate activities of the movement.

But when Uganda came to life, it was

necessary to make concessions to the Zione Zion, so the Congress voted 15,000 francs for the study of Palestine and the diffusion of knowledge about Palestine. Meteorological stations were maintained, out of this fund, in conjunction with the Germans; a magazine was established; but there were no original researches made in Palestine to demonstrate its worth as an agricultural country for immigration. It is evident that a subsidy so inadequate will never serve the purpose. The last congress, as if recognizing the futility of the work, ordered the Palestine Commission to carry on its investigations for industrial results.

So much for what the organization has done.

The policy of assimilation had placed the Jew in an equivocal position. He had been taught to consider himself a German, a Frenchman, etc, but the German and the French had persisted in treating him as a Jew. His conversion to Zionism meant the recovery of his identity; he was made to feel that in a spiritual Zion he could rid himself of the anomalies attendant on life among the nations where he lived. He had felt the incongruity of his existence, and Zionism harmonized his inner life When this satisfaction had been given to him, he rested in the spiritual harmony it had created, but felt no impulsion to go further, and rid himself of the social and economic inequalities which his alienism produced. Nor did the policy of Zionism require of him any specific action.

In the west of Europe, Zionism found its converts among the middle classes and university students, whose economic situation did not press for a change of abode and for ampler means of subsistence. These took, therefore, from Zionism what they required for the harmonization of their own lives, and gave no heed to the demands of the eastern Jews for a place of exit.

The eastern Jews, who considered Zionism from both a spiritual and an economic