Mr. Zangwill and Palestine
Mr. Norman Bentwich, replying to a letter by Mr. Zangwill, which appeared in the London Daily News, writes:
"With excessive pessimism, he thinks that the Jews in all the lands where they are emancipated will disappear within the next two centuries unless there is a recrudescence of anti-Semitism. The Jewish people has always been saved by its minorities, and a remnant will always resist the forces of assimilation. The best reply to Mr. Zangwill has been written by Mr. Zangwill himself. In May, 1903, in a speech on Zionism and the Hirsch Millions he said of Baron de Hirsch:
"He was the greatest dreamer of the ghetto of our generation. One of his dreams was that you could suddenly pluck Jews out of their close-packed ghettos and dump them down on lonely farms at the other end of the world. And yet it is strange that he did not see that Palestine is the only land whose soil would attract them."
"Mr. Zangwill is a greater dreamer of the ghetto than the Baron; since he seems to think that you can suddenly take thousands of Jews out of their ghettos and transform them into sturdy colonists in an untried and undeveloped country. In truth, the economic problem of the individual Jew cannot be solved by an independent Jewish territory, but must be left for the most part to the individual to solve for himself. Zionism, which Mr. Zangwill calls 'the other variation of the territorial idea,' aims rather at the solution of the other problem of the Jew as the warden and bearer of Judaism. Why does Mr. Zangwill now reject Palestine as the land for Jewish settlement? Is it because it is a predetermined territory to which Jewish aspiration has turned for 2,000 years, and he requires a territory free from that prepossession? Or is it because it is semisterile?
"Yet in 1901 Mr. Zangwill, speaking on the commercial future of Palestine, said: 'The Promised Land is a land of promise, and requires only capital and labor to develop it.' Has Palestine or Mr. Zangwill changed during the last ten years? Or is it that the 600,000 Arabs already settled in the country makes Jewish immigration impracticable? Yet in 1901 Palestine, according to Mr. Zangwill, had 'but a small population of Arabs and Fellahin and wandering, lawless, black-mailing Bedouin tribes,' and his appeal then was, 'Restore the country without a people to the people without a country.'
"Mr. Zangwill thinks that the solution of the problem of Judaism is to be found in the transformation of the Jewish religion into a missionary faith. In the same speech of 1903 he said, in his most Zangwillian way, to those who advocated the Jewish mission:
"The only mission I can see is omission. What our preachers and teachers actually preach is that the mission of Israel is submission, for never do they act upon our ideal—our supposed mission of peace and brotherhood upon earth."
"In truth, until the Jews have deepened the consciousness of their special outlook upon life in a free Jewish environment, until they have a spiritual centre from which to radiate influence, they cannot be a light among the nations. For all action and all thought which has influenced the world has come from a national centre. What is required is not a Jewish territory—even if it could be obtained—to be a refuge for the Jew as a vagrant and harassed atom, but the Jewish land to be a home for the Jew as the bearer and warden of Judaism."
Mr. Norman Bentwich is a son of Herbert Bentwich, of London, one of the legal advisors of the Jewish Colonial Trust and an active Zionist. Mr. Bentwich, Jr., is one of the editors of the Jewish Review, which is soon to be issued in London.