Iowa and Massachusetts are co-operative. Fruit growers' co-operative organizations have been formed in nine states with about 100,000 members. More than half the orange business of California is handled by the Southern California Fruit Exchange, a co-operative federation composed of some seventy associations with about four thousand members. It is estimated that one-third of the fruit business of California is in the hands of co-operative associations.
The success of co-operation in agricultural industries and distributing stores is remarkable in contrast to the general failure of co-operation in manufacturing. Now, Mr. Oppenheimer has a good explanation for this phenomenon. He divides co-operative associations into two classes, those that are predominantly buyers and those that are predominantly sellers. A co-operative store is composed of buyers. A co-operative factory of sellers. The members of a co-operative store find their benefit in eliminating the profits ofthe middlemen. It is to the advantage of the members of a co-operative store that the membership should be large. On the other hand, a co-operative factory, the purpose of which is to make profits, does not gain in prosperity with increase of membership. The fewer the members, the greater the dividends to each. The tendency, therefore, of the co-operative store is to expand; that of the cooperative factory, to contract in membership until sooner or later the co-operative factory becomes a capitalist’c undertaking in the hands of a few of the shrewdest and most persistent members.
Now, the agricultural co-operative society, according to Oppenheimer, is essentially a buyers' rather than a sellers' association; and he is speaking of the complete agricultural co-operative association which carries on a variety of farming occupations. The point may, however, be sufficiently illustrated by a dairy association. Each farmer produces a quantity of milk which it is necessary that he should have worked up into higher products —butter, cream,
cheese —and marketed. He buys these services of the co-operative creamery at cost price; or he pays the market price, and the profits are divided among the members of the association in proportion to the amount of milk they have sent in to the creamery. The co-operative dairy association is essentially a buyers' association and it succeeds because it is to the interest of the members that they should be numerous and that the organization be democratic.
The complete farmers' association must succeed for the same reason. Let us imagine our Jewish farmers' colony planted in Palestine. Each farmer cultivates his land in his own way. But there are many advantages that he may obtain from the association. He can get the use of machinery too costly for himself to buy, he can get fertilizer for his own land at cost price; seed and other material may be bought in the same way. Furthermore, he has the advantage of assistance in developing his farm in such matters as drainage, irrigation, building and the storing and marketing of crops.
The advantages issuing from agricultural co-operation that have been mentioned are incontestable and have been proved in a large number of experiments under a great variety of conditions. Dr. Oppenheimer's plan for the Jews in Palestine is, however, of a broader scope than that of a simple farmer's association. He has in mind a co-operative community that shall ultimately include industrial as well as agricultural workers. The agricultural association is to be the beginning and the basis. The rest will grow naturally and spontaneously.
Dr. Oppenheimer is careful to emphas- ize the point that the communities he proposes to establish are not to be communistic. Nevertheless, the land of the community is always to belong to the community. Each farmer will lease his parcel and be as secure upon it as if it were his to all eternity; but he cannot sell it and hence there will be no land speculation in these