I now return to the word "belong."
If an individual "belong" to a nation, as I mean it, it is a matter of his own inclination and desire. It is not subject to rules, regulations or limitations. That is a "spiritual" belonging. But if part of the nation, so constituted, reaches an official or political existence, there arises another kind of "belonging," namely a "civic" belonging. The individual then becomes a citizen of an official or political nation. It is this form of belonging that is subject to limitations and conventional arrangement.
If an individual embraces, in his heart, two nationalities, but only in spirit, both have an independent existence. They may both have equal potency. But if an individual belong civilly to two official or political nations, then one nation must be subordinate or subordinated to the other, and the individual belongs to the primary nation through the secondary one. A Bohemian, for instance, belongs to Austria, through his relationship to Bohemia. An individual cannot belong civilly to two different and completely separated nations, but he may civilly belong to one official or political nation and simultaneously feel a sense of solidarity with another official nation, realizing that that other official nation expresses the second national inclination of his heart.
For instance, a German who is a citizen of Austria, belongs not only spiritually but also officially and civilly, using these terms almost synonymously, to the Austrian nation. At the same time he may feel in sympathy with Germany in preference to other countries like France or England. He realizes that German is the official expression of the larger German nation to which he spiritually belongs.
Sometimes the word "belonging" is used by persons who forget that it is not used in the sense of forcible belonging; they forget that they are confronted by a particular situation; namely, that a man may be attached to an official nation against his
will through force and compulsion. This kind of belonging I term compulsory belonging. An instance of it is the Armenian dependence under Abdul Hamid.
u es AI] these definitions throw light upon the position in which the Jews are placed among the nations of the world. Many Jews, while belonging not only spiritually but also civillv. to the official part of one nation, feel at the same time a sense of spirituar' belonging to that part of humanity which constitutes the Jewish nation. This is entirely justifiable and in accordance with the general laws of psychology, as nıanifested also in the lives of other nations, regardless of the fact whether those »ationse have develoned into official nations.
Does it then make any difference to the Jews as a whole whether they are classed "one way or the other?" It is apparent that we must first know the truth; and it does make a great difference if we.present ourselves to the world in the garb of truth, or if we appear at all times in the dark robes of falsehood. If a person is placed in the witness box and gives one false answer, it may later develop, that, in the course of the inquiry, he may be compelled to commit one perjury after the other, commit any kind of wrong, in order to account for the original lie, which is the basis of his testimony, in order further to appear consistent with his first statement. He may involve himself in a network of crime and falsehood, of which he had no thought when the investigation began.
What is true of the individual is also true of a nation. The truth is the best policy. It gives you standing, and guides you aright in whatever position you may find yourself. You will feel at ease. Your position will be dignified, strong, creating confidence and respect. A lie, at all times, is dangerous, immoral, and also of no practical use in the long run. The answer to the question is therefore obvious. First, we must find out for ourselves what we actually are, and when we are asked, we are bound to answer with the truth.