The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 3 · March 1910
76printed page
scan 4 of 52
76
THE MACCABAEAN

as he describes in his "Derekh T'shuliah" with the Biblical verse: "Behold, whatsoever I builded I destroy, and whatsoever I planted, I root out——and thou seekest great things for thyself? Do not seek any!" Thereupon he came out with an article in Russian: "The General Jewish Question and Palestine," where he pointed to the re-establishment of the Jews in Palestine as the only solution of the Jewish problem. This article did not remain without effect upon Russian Jewry; and followed immediately by Dr. Pinsker's famous brochure, "Auto-emancipation," it contributed to the creation of the Chovevei Zion movement, of which Dr. Pinsker became president and Lilienblum, secretary.

Thus from a victim of the Haskalah period, one of the most negative periods in Jewish history, Lilienblum became one of the initiators of the new, constructive period and one of its most energetic workers; both with pen and action. Yet with all the ardor and the zeal that Lilienblum displayed in his activity during the second period he could not occupy here the foremost place as he had done during the preceding one He was in his make-up rather the child of the latter period than of the former. He had all the qualities that go to make up the successful controversialist, but he lacked the imagination, the depth of thought and emotion, and also the knowledge, to become a genuine creative power. Not even his first creative article cited above was original with him.

The re-establishment of the Jews as a nation in their own land had been pro- nıulgated before him by Kalisher, Hess, and David Gordon from different points of view and from different motives. It was only by his logical consistency and manly persistency in the national ideal to which he clung from the very beginning of his public activity, that Lilienblum reached the conclusion which many had reached before him. And he reached it, it is true, not a moment too soon or too late. Hence Lilienblum exerted no such telling -influence upon the new creative period as he had done upon the preceding negative one. Yet there was up to the last a freshness of manhood about all Lilien- hlum said and did.

The writings of Lilienblum in the second period are numerous. He contributed to almost every magazine published in Hebrew on "Jewish science" and on topics of the day, wrote considerably also in Russian and Yiddish, and published besides, the following works worth mentioning: "Zerubbabel," a Zionist drama in Yiddish, of no great literary value; "About the regeneration of the Jewish People on Its Own Land" in Russian, containing the article mentioned above, and a few other articles on the same subjects or singular subjects; "Derekh T'shuliah," a third part to the "Hatoth Nurim" treating with the time of transition and "Derekh Laabor Golim," a documentary history of "Hibbath Zion" down to the time of its legalization in Russia.