donor to have his name connected with the nurture of an olive tree, gives the property right in the tree of the National Fund.
The intention of the proposers of this scheme of "dunam" ownership had in mind, doubtless, the awakening of interest in the National Fund, and the extension at once of the real property owned in Palestine by the movement. It is to be regretted that a confusion of purposes has been allowed to enter the National Fund. The National Fund was never intended primarily to be the instrument for the acquisition of land in Palestine, and it is doubtful whether another subdivision of the appeal of the National Fund will result in benefit to the National Fund proper.
Our agitators and workers may have some difficulty, we surmise, in convincing our adherents that the donation of the price of one dunam of land will not vest in them a real property interest, for already we hear of "land" purchases by individual Zionists as being the aim of the new proposition. It becomes our duty, therefore, to make this matter clear, and then, with whatever power we have, proceed to get as large a fund for the purchase of the dunams of land as we possibly can get.
THE NEW YORK KEHILLA.
THE New York Kehilla has passed through its first year's experience and is about to hold its second annual convention. The experiment, in the nature of things, cannot now be satisfactorily judged, but it may be said that the Kehilla has justified at least some of the hopes of its friends. It has made an earnest endeavor to create a central organization, through which the manifold interests of the community should express themselves. It has observed and considered life in Greater New York as a whole, unhampered by petty interests, and has thus been enabled to propose plans which, if realized, will fill serious gaps in the communal life.
Necessarily, what it has accomplished relates itself to what is called Jewish religious life: kashrus, Hebrew education, synagogal regulations, the Sabbath; and if an apology were needed, it may be said that any effort on the part of Jews to rehabilitate their communal state in the goluth, must in large measure be connected with Jewish religious life. You cannot build the framework of a healthy communal life—if it can at all be done in goluth,—without at the same time taking steps to strengtken the so-called religious features of that life. For these religious phenomena are the present and most dependable things about Jewish life No matter how unreligious a Jew may be, he must admit that without kashrus, without the Sabbath, without Hebrew education, without the synagogal establis;ments, there is nothing at all permanent about Jewish life in the goluth. A Kehilla cannot depend for its existence upon an immigration problem, or hoodlum attacks upon Jews, or anti-Jewish statements by police-commissioners or other anti-Semites. A policy of that sort would be passive, or inert and its activity would depend upon special anti-Jewish manifestation. The things tkat arise out of Jewish life itself, that are not the result of external stimulation, these must be taken hold of, strengthened, purified, co-ordinated, in order that, should the external forces show signs of life, a strong, permanent organization may be in a position to meet them.
The work of the New York Kehilla for the establishment of a council of rabbis, its efforts to regulate and improve instruction in chedorim, its work on behalf of legislation that shall give Jewish citizens a fair and equal chance in industrial and commercial competition, its efforts to give the word kosher a legal significance,—all is clearly within the scope of the Kehilla and have been energetically executed, considering the means the Kehilla has had at its command.
The Kehilla is a salvage organization. It is in the nature of a rescuing party.