The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
4printed page
scan 4 of 52
Facsimile · scan 4 of 52
Scan of p. 4
Text · transcribed from the scan

internal task, the development and strengthening of Zionism, demands that the headquarters of our movement remain outside Turkey, beyond the sway of the Turkish rulers. It is easier to influence the countries of European civilization from a city in the center or west of Europe than from Jerusalem, Jaffa or Constantinople.

In the event of negotiations with the Turkish government we are in a better position if we can conduct them outside, than in the capacity of a Turkish organization, that is to say, in the relationship of subjects to their legal rulers. In every other land, where we ask nothing from the government and need maintain no official relations, we enjoy much greater freedom of movement and independence than in Turkey. I think these reasons are clear enough to render further elaboration unnecessary.

Our future lies in Turkey, but our present is temporarily still in Europe and America. For the sake of the future, we must not neglect the present. The present prepares for the future, renders it at all possible.

DISCUSSES MAKING OF BASLE PROGRAM.

It conceives the future within itself as a germ which cannot dispense with the maternal protection for its life and its development. But the saddest impression I have derived during the last month has been the demand which has been loudly advanced from many sides for the alteration of our program. Have those, who raised this cry, completely realized the significance and effect of their demand? We describe the resolution of the first Zionist Congress as our program, because we avoid over-emphasis and intentionally employ sober, businesslike language. But do not be deceived. What we call program in our party and sectional activity is really the concise verbal expression of the two-thousand-year-old historic ideal of Judaism, the goal which has shone before the Jewish people through the night of exile as a bright star, I hope for which the best of our nation underwent super-

natural sufferings and died. Are we to surrender this ideal at the first incident in daily politics? The loud applause with which you gave point to the arguments employed by our President in rejecting a similar thesis satisfies me at this moment as to your views. But let us linger a little longer over this point. What is to be altered in the Basle program? "The idea of the text has become obsolete," it is suggested. That can at once be admitted.

But in the Basle program there is no mention of a charter. The charter was a personal idea of our revered Herzl, an idea which, as its author conceived, could be defended. But he was not able to realize it, and in present circumstances it is immaterial. So let us abandon it calmly, the more calmly inasmuch as it is not essential for our movement and does not in the least go to its root. It was intended to be the means to an end. It is no longer a suitable means. Only a fool clings obstinately to means which are recognized as unserviceable. In an absolutist Turkey, we should have had to demand freedom which, in view of the general serfdom, would have partaken of the nature of special privileges, and would have rendered formal written securities necessary. In a constitutional State, in which all citizens enjoy the freedom they have won, we require no special privileges, and no exceptional treatment. The ordinary law suffices. Therefore let us put Herzl's Charter idea respectfully in the archives of modern Zionism and say no more about it. But what is the objection to the Basle program? We are told that we must no longer say that Zionism strives for the creation of a publicly legally recognized home for the Jewish people. "Publicly legally," it is said, is useless if not dangerous. Honored Congress! I believe I have a right to speak on this point. In spite of the whirl in which mankind lives to-day, and in spite of the shortness of human memory, it has possibly not yet been forgotten that I was mainly responsible for the concrete expression, i. e., for the text of the Basle pro-