national Messianic state in Palestine, but the realization in society and state of the principles of righteousness as enunciated "by the prophets and sages of old......It eliminates from the prayer book all references to the Messiak, the return to Palestine......Having become an American, a German, etc., the Jew cannot pray for himself and his children that he or they may, by an act of divine grace, be made citizens of another state and land, namelv. national Israel in Palastine ”
It is not necessary to cite the resolutions adopted by reform leaders on the religious mission of Judaism which is meant to exclude nationalistic endeavors. They are too numerous to mention. From the Frankfort Conference of reform rabbis, to the Montreal, held in the United States several years ago, after the intitation of the Herzian movement, Zionism had been considered by reform rabbis, in conference, as opposed to their religious pretensions.
The fact that the Union Prayer Book remains the property of the Central Conference; the further fact that a large majority of its members are anti-Zionists; that the Conference remains by its old resolution, “Washington is our Jerusalem and the United States our Zion,” and that nothing has yet been done to alter that resolution or to repudiate it:—these are facts that justify the position that we have taken, that reform Judaism is detrimental to the interests of Zionism.
That does not mean, however, that we despair of ever converting reform Jews to our way of thinking. The leaders who oppose Zionism are slowly losing their hold on their congregations; what they say, on the nationalist side of Jewish events, does not fall upon prejudiced ears, as was the case less than ten years ago. The Zionist view of Jewish life is constantly making converts, and it is only a matter of time before the reform Jews will reconcile their desires for religious progress with the Zionist ideals. But the organizations and the leaders who stand for the exclusion of Zionism from Jewish religious progress cannot be allowed to go on with their work without the criticism of Zionists who see in their present anti-nationalist propaganda an attempt to continue the status quo so far as our national aspirations are concerned. We may think that so-called progress in Jewish religion, while in golus, is impossible without detriment to nationality, but at least, if Zionism is included as one of the principles of reform Judaism, THE MACCABAEAN may simple deplore that fact and point out that all progress in Jewish life is impossible without the realization of our national hopes. Until reform Judaism, in its official aspects, will have revised its anti-national dogmas and principles, THE MACCABAEAN, we trust, will continue its policy of opposition to that sort of Judaism.
