Orthodox, and has nothing whatever to do with theological differences within our faith. We are opposed to all enemies of Nationalism, under whatever name they may sail; but as a matter of fact, tne enemies of Zionism are found within and without the reform movement, and so are its friends. I would have little objection to most of the articles referred to, if it were made to appear very clearly that they represent the individual views of yourself or of any of your contributors; but in publishing them as you do now, I believe vou are exceedine vour editorial authority.
Yours, with Zion's greetings,JOSEPH JASIN.
The editor of THE MACCABAEAN Teas- serts that Zionism is opposed to reform Judaism, and declares that it would be the height of folly to adopt any other policy. The reform movement from its inception has been opposed to Zionism, and kas deliberately repudiated from its scheme of religion every remnant of nationalistic sentiment. By its opposition, it is acting in a manner detrimental to the interests of our movement. It becomes the duty, therefore, of a Zionist organ to treat as opponents those whp proclaim their opposition at every opportunity. Representing Zionism in America, we venture to assert that the Federation of American Zionists will be found supporting the position we have taken. There may be differences of opinion as to the method employed, but on the principal issue, there can be and will be but one opinion.
It is true, as Mr. Jasin says, that Zionism is neither reform nor orthodox, but we may distinguish between enemies and friends. We know that reform Judaism is militantly opposed The JSON for the image contains the following values: {
It is not a theological difference; it is not a matter of belief; it is opposition to our endeavors and ideals in a concrete, practical manner. We do not care to distinguish between theological or political ideas. The ideas of reform Judaism are destructive of Zionism; that is their intention. Having discarded its theological cloak to denounce Zionism, it cannot escape censure.
"We are opposed to all enemies of nationalism," says Mr. Jasin. That is exactly the position of THE MACCABAEAN. Does Mr. Jasin mean to assert that reform Judaism is not opposed to Jewish nationalism? It is admitted that there are a number of reform rabbis who are Zionists, but as members of the Central Conference of American Rabbis, or as rabbis of congregations that are represented in the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, their equivocal position cannot be used as evidence to the contrary.
The Central Conference of American Rabbis is the publisher of the Union Prayer Book. In this book, according to Dr. David Philipson, the historian of the reform movement, "the characteristic doctrines of the reform movement, which differentiate it from traditionalism, find constant expression: the belief in the coming of the Messianic era instead of a personal Messiah; the universalism of Israel's mission as the priest-people in place of the nationalism involved in the belief in the return to Palestine, the establishment of the Jewish state......"
Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, as a theologian, sums up what reform Judaism stands for, in the Jewish Encyclopedia, volume 10, page 348. He says:
"Reform conceives of the destiny of Israel as not bound up in the return to Palestine, and not involving national political restoration under a Messianic King ......Israel is not in exile......Its dispersion was a necessary experience in the realization and execution of its Messianic duty. The goal of Jewish history is not a