The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
2printed page
scan 2 of 52
2
THE MACCABAEAN

ledge of the facts. I have not been appointed either the official or the semi-official defender of the leaders, but like every Zionist, I have the right, and like every fair observer the duty to take up the cudgels on their behalf when I see them unfairly attacked and their activity misinterpreted. I think the leaders are deserving of great commendation for not allowing themselves to be drawn by the lack of moderation, of a section of our coadjutors, but kept cool amid all the feverish excitement, and were able to withstand the tremendous pressure brought to bear on them from all sides. Let us subject the facts of the case to a calm examination.

OUR POSITION WITH REFERENCE TO THE TURKISH REVOLUTION.

What has happened? How far do the events affect us? What new duties for the present and the future do they involve for us? By the bold action of brave and idealist patriots despotism in Turkey was overthrown and the Empire was led along the road of constitutional life after good European patterns. Therefore, we rejoice, not merely as Zionists, not merely as Jews, but simply as men, who joyfully acclaim every progress in the world, are inspired by every example of disinterested and objective effort, and heartily wish every people freedom, order and peace. I desire especially, if in less eloquent words, to repeat this to the Turkish people, which has always shown itself generous towards us and to which we owe an eternal debt of gratitude for the hospitable reception accorded our forefathers driven from Spain four hundred years ago, and with which we hope to establish specially friendly relations by the realization of the objects of Zionism. But, with all our enthusiasm for Turkish freedom, we must not forget that the revolution in Constantinople was, after all, not a Zionist event, not a Jewish event, but a Turkish event; that we are still not Jewish subjects; that we have no direct part in the internal changes of the Turkish Empire, but follow them—albeit with the warmest possible

interest would be tactlessly, impertinent and stupid were we to intervene.

That is one answer to those who who desire to see immediate relations established between Zionism and the Young Turkish rulers. Those who make these demands have palpably not realized that the Young Turks are merely one party in the Ottoman Empire and that they do not constitute the Ottoman Empire itself. At present the Young Turks are the ruling party. Everyone of us is at liberty to assess their achievements hitherto as high as he will, and to show them the warmest sympathy, to wish them a long enjoyment of power and even to believe in that long enjoyment; but the Zionist movement must not identify itself with any one Turkish party. It is impossible for the present or even the future of Zionism to be bound up with the fate of a single Ottoman party. And, above all, it must avoid creating the impression of wanting to intervene in party warfare in Turkey. Let us curb our impatience. When those Zionists who desire to live the new life of our people in the old home of our fathers have become thorough citizens, they will have the right and the opportunity to participate with all the warmth of their temperament in the internal political life of their fatherland, to join the party of their choice, to champion it without reserve, and to attack its foes with as much violence as they like. But for the moment common sense and good taste impose on us a reserve which will be immeasurably more appreciated by all Turkish parties than premature and uncalled-for zeal. The Young Turkish party would not have thanked us if we had prematurely approached them and offered them assistance, which, as a matter of fact, we were not in a position to furnish.

"The center of gravity of Zionism must henceforth be transferred to Turkey" was the cry that resounded on many sides. That is a word-juggle and nothing else. Let us blow away this verbal froth and come to close quarters