probably because they were proud of it.
Mr. Mack. Do not infer from that that the Jew is not proud to be a Jew? He is.
Rep. Bennet. Has not one of your coreligionists who comes from Russia the same right, when he comes to Ellis Island, to say he is a Jew that an Irishman who comes from Belgium has to say he is an Irishman?
Mr. Mack. I should say not, because the Irish man who comes from Belgium undoubtedly is still an English subject. He is an Irishman.
The Chairman. Let me ask one question that has occured to me as this discussion has gone? Suppose we adopt your views of classification, would it not result in this; that every person who comes from the British dominions must be classified as English?
Mr. Mack. As British.
Senator Lodge. Absolutely.
The Chairman. And from Germany, as a German?
Mr. Mack. Yes.
The Chairman. And from Austria as Austrian?
Mr. Mack. Yes, except tkat Austria recognizes seventeen nationalities.
The Chairman. And from Russia, would they not be claimed as Russians?
Mr. Mack. Yes. But we are not dealing with those people. The question I was addressing myself was to your classification of Americans in America.
The Chairman. Yes, I understand that.
Senator Lodge. We are not classifying Americans in America.
The Chairman. It seems to me Mr. Wolf’s contention would come to this: We would be compelled to go back on the whole question of race and take them by their political associations.
Senator Lodge. The classification, of course, would be worthless.
The Chairman. Yes.
Rep. Bennet. You would not deny to Mr. Aronsohn, when he came to this
country, the right to classify himself as a Jew?
Mr. Mack. No.
Rep. Bennet. Although under the geographical classification he is a Turk.
Mr. Aaronsohn. "An Ottoman; not a Turk."
Mr. Wolf. It has been stated that your classification has been in existence since 1820. It only became a factor against which we protested within the last ten years or fifteen years, since the enforced emigration from Russia and Romania commenced. I say "enforced emigration" advisedly.
Rep. Bennet. I agree with you.
Mr. Mack. The main point about it is that the Jews in this country do not want anything done by the United States Government which in their judgment—and that is submitted to your judgment—is of no particular value that they can observe, but which they are dead sure will be used to stir up and will lend itself to stirrine un racial feeling.
Mr. Wolf. That is it exactly.
The Chairman. I think we understand the position which has been taken upon this matter. There are other questions, Mr. Wolf, which you said you wished to discuss.
Mr. Wolf. I do not know whether the Commission intends to make recommendations regarding legislation with respect to the admission of immigrants. If so, I have some ideas to advance and views to express, as I have had a great deal of experience in preventing the deportation of aliens. I have had several conferences with the authorities at Ellis Island.
The Chairman. I will say in regard to that point that the information which has been gathered by the agents of the Commission is now in process of tabulation, and it has come to that stage where we begin to get results. But the Commission have had only one meeting previous to that of to-day to take up that material and go over it with any considerable care.