zen, independent of every other consideration. What he is religiously, or by faith, or by non-faith, is his business. That is a right granted to him by the Constitution and the institutions of the land, and every patriotic citizen irrespective of faith should aid us in this laudable attempt.
Mr. Mack. There is one practical reason to be interposed against this classification, particularly in dealing with people who are here. To stir up race feeling is, we all know, highly injurious. There is no question of the existence in this country among some people of anti-Semitism, just as there is in Germany and in other countries.
Mr. Wheeler. There is no question of the existence among some narrow-minded people of a feeling which may be called anti-Romanism.
Mr. Mack. Not the slightest. But you do not classify Christians as Protestants or Roman Catholics.
Senator Lodge. In the census—
Mr. Mack. I am talking about your work here now. You are not classifying the Protestants and the Catholics in any manner racially, but you are classifying the Jews. Now, when the Jews disclaim that racial feeling—those who are Americans, and the ones you are classifying are largely American citizens—and when they say to you “These people are English in their parentage,” “Those people are German in their parentage,” “These people are French in their parentage,” and you classify them as Jews, then you immediately raise the feeling that they are of a foreign race; that they are foreign to us; that they are not Americans the same as we are. Therefore, they are strangers; and we all know the prejudice, as such, is based largely and fundamentally, wkatever it may be aggravated by, on the idea of the stranger. There always was a prejudice against the stranger, and you emphasize the fact that the Jew here is
a Jew like those of foreign nations—strangers to our land. That is the thing we resent.
Senator Lodge. We classify the Germans as Germans. How can we do it otherwise? We are all immigrants.
Mr. Mack. You and I know that, Senator. We feel that; we realize that; andyou have none of the feeling that theaverage man on the streets has, who, whenyou go to him with such returns, sees thatthe Jew is distinct from all the others."These people are Germans. All right.We get along mighty well with the Germans. We always have. Even the Irishand the Germans do pretty well togetherhere as the representatives of two greatnations of the world.
Senator Lodge. Is there an Irish nation?
Mr. Mack. They want to be very strongly. They would resent being called Englishmen.
Senator Lodge. They would, and I would resent it if I were an Irishman.
Mr. Mack. You would have to call them Great Britainers. You have never used that term. Therefore you say Scotchmen, Englishmen, Welshmen and Irishmen. But that is geographical.
Senator Lodge. An Irishman is classified as an Irishman, no matter where he comes from.
Mr. Mack. No matter whether he believes in home rule or not?
Senator Lodge. No matter what country he comes from —whether Australia or Canada.
Rep. Bennet. Eight came from Belgium, thirty from France, one from Germany.
Mr. Mack. They probably were not subjects of those countries.
Senator Lodge. You do not know that. It is pure assumption.
Mr. Mack. I do not know that. But you do not know the contrary.
Mr. Wolf. Was there anything in their appearances to indicate that, except from their names? They claimed to be Irish
