The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
24printed page
scan 24 of 52
Facsimile · scan 24 of 52
Scan of p. 24
Text · transcribed from the scan

Senator Lodge. It is not a question as to where a man happens to live or what his allegiance is. If we were to classify men according to their allegiance, we would classify them in a manner which would be useless.

Mr. Wolf. You claim if a man is once a Jew, he is always a Jew.

Mr. Lodge. Yes; if he is of the Jewish race.

Mr. Mack. If one parent is a Jew and the other is not —

Senator Lodge. There you mix the blood.

"Mr. Mack. Where would you put. D’Israeli’s children, if he had any? Where would you put Felix Mendelssokn’s children, if he had any? Mendelssohn became a Christian. I do not know where you would put his children. He considered himself a German, and the Germans, in large part, except the anti-Semitic lement, consider him a German.

Senator Lodge. Your proposition is that the classification is according to religion. That is certainly not the fact.

Mr. Mack. Then of what value is your classification?

Senator Lodge. The Jews are classified according to their race and not theirreligion.

Mr. Mack. What is its value?

Senator Lodge. All classifications must be more or less inexact.

Mr. Mack. Take the Jews who come from Germany, whose ancestors have lived in Germany three or four hundred years, ever since Spain drove them out of that country, who have become thoroughly identified in every way with their German neighbors, and are deemed by all to be Germans, except by the anti-Semitic element; of what possible value is it to anybody to classify them as Jews simply because they adhere to the Jewish religion?

Senator Lodge. Because there is a general belief that the Jews are a strongly defined race.

Mr. Mack. I think they are strongly defined.

Senator Lodge. I mean they have maintained their racial status in a very extraordinary way.

Mr. Mack. I am not ethnologist enough to say. I think they have kept their blood purer, perhaps, than many other nations. But intermarriage has been common.

Senator Lodge. There is a general belief, I think widely accepted, that they are a race. There are, I know, bodies of Jews who are not racially Jewish at all. Doctor Adler refers to one tribe in Abyssinia. If we had here an immigration of Abyssinians they would never be classified as Jews, no matter what their faith might be. There are Christian Abyssinians, and it is a curious form of Christianity. There is also there a tribe of Jews called Falashas. But if there was any immigration to this country from that country, they would be classified as Abyssinians—all of them, whether Christians or Jews. They would not be classified as Jews on account of their religion.

Mr. Mack. Take a Jewish immigrant from this country into England. Of what possible value would it be to England for England to classify him, not as an American, but as a Jew? Of what possible value would it be for England to classify you as an American and me as a Jew? I do not know you could claim to be any more of an American that I am because your ancestors have been here probably ten. generation and mine only three generations, although I know of plenty of Jews who have been here for eight generations.

Mr. Wheeler. You would not be classified other than as an American.

Mr. Mack. I would not?

Mr. Wheeler. Under the present system.

Mr. Mack. Now Senator Lodge just said that he would classify Beaconsie as a Jew and not as an Englishman.

Senator Lodge. Racially.

Mr. Wolf. That is the same case.