The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
23printed page
scan 23 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
23

fied according to their religion. They are British subjects.

Mr. Wolf. Certainly.

Senator Lodge. But we classify them as Irish, because they are Irish, and undoubtedly there is a great deal of mixed blood in Ireland—English, Scotch and Welsh blood.

Mr. Wolf. That is altogether geographically, and so with respect to the seventeen Austrian provinces.

Senator Lodge. The Irish are not classified geographically. An Irishman is classified as an Irish immigrant wherever he may come from.

Mr. Wolf. You seem to forget certainly are sufficiently versed in history of all people, and especially the people I represent,—to know that when a Jew is spoken of a Jew in faith is meant.

Senator Lodge. Not at all.

Mr. Wolf. And the race has absolutely nothing to do with it.

Senator Lodge. There is where we start off with a vast difference. I deny that this classification is according to religion.

Mr. Wolf. It should not be.

Senator Lodge. It is purely a racial classification, and I used the illustrations I did to establish that.

Rep. Bennet. Does not the word "Hebrew" come from the fact that those people were known as the descendants of Heber and is it not used in Genesis as a racial term?

Mr. Wolf. Yes!

Rep. Bennet. It is not based on religion at all.

Mr. Wolf. But a great many races have disappeared, or been assimilated and mingled with the people among them whom they lived.

Rep. Bennet. That is true. But here is a race that has not.

Mr. Wolf. Why not? Do you mean to say I am any less an American because I happen to be a Jew in faith?

Rep. Bennet. No; nor do I deny that I am in part Irish, even though I am an American.

Mr. Wolf. I honor you for it.

Senator Lodge. We are none of us Americans racially. We are Americans politically and geographically, but we are not Americans racially.

Mr. Wolf. No, I suppose the true Americans are the Indians.

Senator Lodge. Certainly.
Rep. Bennet. Or the Moundbuilders.

Mr. Wheeler. I must say that I never understood the word "Jew" or the word "Hebrew" to describe a religion. I have running through my mind now a half a dozen prominent families in San Francisco, who attend Christian churches. But we know them all as Jews.

Mr. Wolf. You know them as a class, but we could not recognize them as Jews. Mr. Judah P. Benjamin has been recognized as a Jew born, but he was an Episcopalian. That does not follow at all. There are a number of Jews who have become converted or who have married Christians.

Senator Lodge. Do they cease thereby to be Jews? Does "Jew" become a wrong description?

Mr. Wolf. They certainly cease to be Jews.

Senator Lodge. Is no man a Jew unless he is of the Jewish faith?

Mr. Wolf. As a matter of glorification and an illustration of the genius inherent in the Jew as such, when born as such, as I stated at the inception, a great many claim D'Israeli, Heine, B rne, Mendelssohn, Barthold and other great celebrities in all the walks of literature, arts and sciences, as Jews, but they become Christians.

Mr. Julian W. Mack. Permit me to say a word. If D'Israeli had come to this country, after he had attained his fame, he certainly would have said, in answer to the question asked him at the port, that he was an Englishman.

Senator Lodge. He would have been classed racially as a Jew.

Mr. Mack. Would some officer of the port have that power?