THE MACCABAEAN
THE NEW YORK PUBLIC LIBRARY 542807
ASTOR, LENOX AND TILDEN FOUNDATIONS.
THE POSITION OF ZIONISM TO-DAY
Congress Address by MAX NORDAU
SINCE our last meeting in the Hague, over two years ago, the event which has most profoundly moved and most continuously occupied every Zionist, and with which the greater part of the opening speech of our President (greeted by you with so much applause) dealt, was curiously enough not a Zionist event. It was the bloodless revolution consummated on the 24th of June, 1908, in Constantinople, and which had a bloody sequel on the 13th of April of the current year. When the surprising news was given to the world that in Turkey absolutism had been overthrown, the Sultan had given his assent to a liberal constitution, and the Turkish Empire was to be changed into a constitutional democracy, the Zionist section of the Jewish people was seized with a veritable fever. The regrettable instability of the Jewish temperament, our unfortunate nervousness, was manifested in evil shape. The Zionist press and Zionist meetings indulged in fearful exaggeration. If we were to believe all these tumultous demonstrations, the revolution in Constantinople was by far the most important event that had occurred in Jewish history for many centuries. Zionism, we were told, had suddenly been brought within arm's length of its goal, which, it was thought, could be seized with the stretchedout hand. A modern liberal Turkey was bound to receive us with open arms; we merely had to ask, to obtain the right of immigration into Palestine. The Zionist movement must immediately adapt itself to the altered conditions; it must at once take up an entirely new position, abandon all its old methods, and henceforth work
on totally different lines. Everyone turned with expectancy to headquarters; they awaited some action on the spot, some immediate intervention in the new developments in Turkey. They were disappointed, despondent, bitter when this action did not immediately result.
"What are they thinking about in Cologne?" a hundred voices exclaimed. "Do the people there not rightly appreciate the enormous importance of the events in Turkey? Will they let this great movement, that will not recur for centuries, go by unutilized?" And the advisers, whom the Jewish people has notoriously never lacked, began to pour out the stores of their counsel. They told us that the leaders must immediately open up communications with the Turkish rulers, and by enlightenment, persuasion, and offers of assistance, win them over for the objects of Zionism. We were told it would be best if the leaders transferred their headquarters to Constantinople and convened our Congress there. But, above all, the Basle program must be completely altered in order that it might correspond with the changed situation. Much of that which was proposed or demanded at the time was sensible—so sensible that it occurred to every Zionist who did not find it necessary to belch it forth excitedly in tones of angry impatience. Other demands were so curious as to be almost incredible and I pass them over in benevolent silence, as it is not to my taste and this is not the proper occasion or place for me to expose our friends to ridicule, who erred only out of zeal, out of a lack of political experience, through: insufficient know-
