The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
17printed page
scan 17 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
17

ernment to know the quality of the alien immigration coming into these ports, we welcome a classification which will enable the Jewish people to prove that they are physically, morally and spiritually good material for the United States.

As American citizens, we believe it is our duty to assist our government in arriving at correct conclusions as to desirable immigration. If our people are undesirable, we are aiding in the perpetration of fraud upon this government if we oppose a fair investigation of the facts, and the classification of Jews as such is merely a necessary step in the direction of ascertaining the facts.

The Jewish immigrant, we assert, is not an undesirable. The United States needs immigration of all sorts, and more especially it needs the immigration of a people who bring with them religious, industrial and moral values, who are industrious, ambitious, and eager for democratic liberty. A scientific classification of

alien immigration will prove that assertion. An evasion of the test will foment distrust and create an impression of unknown dangers which is just the meat the anti-restrictionist feeds upon.

The Jewish people cannot afford to adopt a policy that smacks of Jesuitism; it is bound therefore, to repudiate any policy that is in essence based upon the theory that the end justifies the means; that is the ground upon which Judge Mack and Mr. Wolf stand, and the American Jewish Committee and the Union of American Hebrew Congregations are responsible for the utterances of their agents.

For the length of the testimony, THE MACCABAEAN must offer an apology to its readers. As a matter of record, however, it deserves to be published in full in this magazine. It becomes all the more urgent to publish it in full, owing to the disinclination of the American Jewish Committee, for reasons best known to itself, to publish it on its own account.

The Hon. Simon Wolf and Judge Julian Mack Testify Before Congressional Commission on Immigration

Washington, D. C., December 4, 1909.

The Commission met at 10:00 o'clock a. m. Present: Senators Dillingham, (chairman), and Lodge; Representatives Howell and Bennet; Messrs. Jenks, Niell and Wheeler.

STATEMENT OF SIMON WOLF.

The Chairman. Mr. Simon Wolf, who is present, has asked for an opportunity to present certain views, and I have asked him to be present this morning. Mr. Wolf, we are now ready to hear you.

Mr. Wolf. Chairman and gentlemen, I do not know on exactly what lines you wish me to speak, but it may be you desire to ask me certain questions, and, if so, I shall be very glad to answer them as best I can.

The Chairman. You wrote me a letter saying you desired to be heard on certain questions.

Mr. Wolf. Yes.

The Chairman. It is for the reasons stated in your letter that we have appointed the meeting for this morning.

Mr. Wolf. One of the questions I wish to bring to the attention of the Commission is the classification of immigrants by faith. That is what it amounts to, as far as the Jewish immigration is concerned. Some years ago that question arose in the Immigration Bureau, when Mr. Powderly was Commissioner General, and I was invited to New York. We argued the matter there at length, and the Bureau finally come to the conclusion to eliminate the word "Jew" from the immigration list, and I supposed that the subject had ended then and there. But it has been revived, and the word is now being used, I believe, not only by the authorities, but its use is also contemplated in the report of your honorable Commission, as I have