The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
204printed page
scan 22 of 52
204
THE MACCABAEAN

censured for making too little mention of. "Dr. Silverman has been asleep for three years," said Dr. Kohler disgustedly.

When Dr. Philipson, and Dr. Kohler, and Dr. Enelow—all members of the committee—were through pitching into Dr. Silverman and demanding a retraction, Dr. Silverman suddenly found a passage in the records of the previous Conference, which, he thought, bore out his view:

"Here you are!" he shouted. "I knew that I was right. I am telling you the Gospel truth!"

That was too much for even the rabbis; and they broke into a roar.

* * *

On Tuesday, the final day of the session, the Conference settled down to hear Rabbi Foster's paper on "The Synagogue and the Workingman," which had been laid over from last year's meeting. It was vigorously applauded. Even Rabbi Stephen S. Wise, whom in its allusions to "free synagogues" it somewhat displeased, raved over it. He characterized it as "a symposium of platitudinous pomposity." He characterized it for twenty minutes. The time allotted to each speaker was three minutes; but Dr. Wise insisted that unless the Conference allowed him his own time in rebutting the arguments and charges in the paper, he would "find other places where he would be heard." They allowed him to take his time.

* * *

There was more of "that glorious unity and harmony" at the discussion of the intermarriage which was finally forced on the floor by Dr. Schulman's resolution, in the last hours of the Conference. Here is the symposium:

"Do not bind your hands, brethren, by a synodical pronouncement against mixed marriages,” pleaded Rabbi Moses.

marriages,” pleaded Rabbi Moses. “All Jewish tradition forbids such marriages,” said Dr. Kohler. “Only a few days ago a very prominent layman of this city declared to me that the Conference would lay itself open to the charge of gross cowardice if it refused to take a stand in this matter.”

“The law does not forbid it,” maintained Rabbi Gries (he who had refused to translate Brainin), “it only says something about a 'Kidusha'—a sanctification—”

"Kidushin doesn't mean sanctification; it means marriage," corrected Dr. Schulman, with a broad smile.

"I have married Jews and non-Jews repeatedly," upspake Rabbi Kornfeld, of Columbus. "Geiger says that that is permissible."

"Judaism will not last four generations if it goes forth that this Conference sanctions mixed marriages," said Dr. Harris, of Temple Israel.

Then came the last word, by Rabbi Elkin, of New Haven, the oldest member of the Conference:

“Why do you dance on two stands?” he cried. “You use the Talmud when it suits you, and reject it when it doesn't. The question is not whether we dare discard the Talmudic law; but whether we dare discard the Mosaic law.”

There were loud shouts of "Yes! Yes!"

"If so," said Elkin, "I declare for once and all, let us go over to Unitarianism. And then we won't need rabbis at all; and what will become of your $8,000 and $10,000 salaries?"

J.