The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
184printed page
scan 2 of 52

more loyal, more devoted, more Jonathon to David than David Wolffsohn. Some part of him was the “David Litwak” of Herzl’s “Altneuland.” Of fine appearance, genial to a fault, a successful business man who could spare time and money, of Russian descent, and German education, lacking the normal Jewish complexities, but qualified even to the extent of speaking Hebrew—to him went the mantle of the successorship. There was no egoism in Wolffsohn. Not even his wife imagined he was a second Herzl. Nordau lacked the physical energies and lives by his profession. He refused to be an aspirant—and there are few things so noble in the modern story of his willingness to be second-in-command. Gaster, yes, Gaster was a possible Herzl. Brilliant, poetic, eloquent, scholar, linguist, what-not—but he could not be leader. He had pursued too much the “gentle art of making enemies,” to be popular. Once he belonged to the fighting clan, but he had been disloyal, he was set aside, the feud has never ended. Besides, he is a Rabbi and Zionism could not accept Rabbinic leadership. The only other possible claimant was Ussischkin—a great leader of small ideas. Intrepid, brave, hard worker, but unsympathetic, and a bitter opponent of Herzl and the Herzlian policies, he was unthinkable, even to his followers.

Wolffsohn then was the Jewish Taft to Herzl's Roosevelt. And those who saw him at the eighth congress, say he has grown with the office. He has exhibited strength and resourcefulness. He has done some things as Herzl would have done them, in others he has lacked the dash of the cavalry leader. We expected more of him since the change in Turkey, but we can admire his silence. He refused ta jump for Mesopotamia because it had Schiff's endorsement; whereas Zangwill could not restrain his eagerness. He found conditions in Constantinople too unstable for lasting results, so he prepared for a waiting policy. He has plodded and he has patience. Those who

set him in Herzl's chair—the living remnant—are with him, but he has less courage to command them, and the battle has become more and more one of unifying the Zionists, rather than that of hurling the mass group of Zionists at Jewry and then at the world.

And so as we write the ninth congress approaches, Wolffsohn is on the defensive and from a distance, it is apparent that an attempt will be made to change the leadership. Ussischkin may make an attempt to gain it. We cannot help admiring this bullet-headed unsuave exponent of a meliorist policy. His passion is for Zion—not for Zionism. The success of his aspirations seems doubtful and the play of policy seems—from a distance—to be the shifting of the leadership to Prof. Warburg, who has made every federation office groan with his plans and appeals for Palestinian work. Warburg was not known as a Zionist till after Kishineff. He was probably more in sympathy with the abortive East-African scheme than any of all the group who said "yes" on the vote which closed that famous debate. His policies would appeal to the old Chovevi Zionists—and well, somehow, the writer guesses the leadership will remain with Wolffsohn. The wish is not exactly father to the thought. Wolffsohn is too honest not to be willing to make way for a stronger man. That stronger man is not, and the strength must be created by the adoption of a new attitude among Zionists towards the movement—we must place the leadership in the hands of the Zionists, the democracy must be taught to assert itself. How to do it? When the reports of the ninth congress are before us, we will discuss this question in detail.

In the meantime, we confess to the anti-Zionists that we have differences and that there are men among us who aspire to leadership. Let them make what use they will of their parrot cries, for it is only through the struggles over honest differences, and honest desires for office that a people can acquire self-government.