The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
199printed page
scan 17 of 52
Facsimile · scan 17 of 52
Scan of p. 199
Text · transcribed from the scan

"Well, wait a second! If you think of the case of some acquaintance, one whom you know, as the saying is, from head to foot and from childhood up—have you one like that?"

"A number!"

'If you will think of such a one, and consider carefully, you will easily perceive that his character is not of a single pattern, but welded together from many separate pieces; that you can tell where each portion came from. You will say, for example, that he looks like his mother, is a kot-head like his father, inherits his mannerisms from an uncle; that his knowledge he owes to such and such a teacher, who influenced him to a considerable extent; that he has acquired certain qualities from his school companions. In later life his parents-in-law exercised some influence upon him; if he went to another city, especially a larger one, another change took place. A wife also contributes to the result; when one becomes the father of children one also alters considerably. Business likewise leaves its imprint upon the soul.

"And not alone in the case of an individual is this so. The same thing is true of a collectivity, particularly of a nation, and still more so of a nation that lives among other and different nations. You do not know all the Jews in all the lands that they inhabit, yet you do know the French, German, Galicians, Polish and Russian Jews resemble each other but little. It is very rarely even that they get along together. Each one has acquired unmerous opinions and customs from his particular school."

"But the spark of Judaism?"

“Ah, but the foreign ashes that cover that spark! The pot-sherds of old and new vessels that have been placed over it to be kept warm—that is something entirely different! And for how many generations has that been going on, that covering with ashes, those foreign pots!”

"If, to-day, let us suppose, the resurrection were to occur, Moses, our teacher,would hardly recognize any of us, and

we him surely not; also one generation would deny the other.

"From every nation we learn something, good or bad; and through how many lands have we passed, among how many nations have we dwelt! If we should have taken from each but a single custom, a single thought, and have bequeathed it to posterity, we should even then have a 'mixed multitude' in our consciousness! At our very outset from Egypt we took along a mixed multitude; in Babylonia we learned something, in Persia we nibbled a little, sponged a little from the Greeks, borrowed from the Arabs, and when in Spain the Christians were burning heretics, our rabbis were engaged in somewhat milder persecutions.

“This being true, how can you know who you are, what is speaking out of you, whom you are believing? It may be that that which you are zealously guarding as the apple of your eye, as a precious gem from Mount Sinai, is only a magician's crystal from ¡Egypt! That which you think is a Jewish habit, comes to us from one or another of the miserable occupations which were forced upon us!”

"And does history explain all that?"

"All that, and much, much more!"

I finally brought my listener to the point where he was curious to know "from what history is written." "A tale," he says, "one invents, but history must naturally be taken from somewhere."

"Not from somewhere—from a thousand somewheres! Or to put it the other way, where is the spot in this world without a trace of our history? The Egyptians pictured us and described us on the pyramids; the Medes and Persians did not forget us; the Greeks have beautifully besmirched us; Rome made special laws for us; the Middle Ages raised a hue and cry about us, they sat in judgment on us, issued decrees, recorded all our transgressions—!"

“Thus, thus, everywhere are scattered our monuments; and so on our side also much has been written. One must know