The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
197printed page
scan 15 of 52
Facsimile · scan 15 of 52
Scan of p. 197
Text · transcribed from the scan

"You can take it as a general principle, my dear friend: 'To love means to know.' To love the whole Jewish people means to be attached not to twenty or thirty Jews, but to all the preceeding generations and to the whole of the present generation which is scattered far and wide. A people or a nation is constituted so to speak, like a cone of sugar; at the top is the narrow point of beginning—Father Abraham in our case—farther down it gets wider and wider; our cone is not symmetrical; mice have bitten through the center, water has moistened it. The lower down you go the more the figure divides and cleaves asunder; between the various parts whole oceans flow, deserts extend and kingdoms spread out. And to love the Jews means to love the whole figure. To love means to be acquainted, to know everything, to have everything in."

My friend does not give in as yet, but he goes so far as to lower his head in thought.

“There’s no denying it,” he remarks a few minutes later, “it is rather interesting.”

“It is more than interesting,” I reply. “It is essential. It is one of the foundations upon which rests the whole of Judaism, the entire 'cone of sugar.' Just consider, we are a very old people, and yet, in this respect other nations are apparently wiser than we. Not only the European nations, who write, read and study history; not only the Romans, the Greeks, the cultured nations of old, who preserved their history as the apple of their eye; and not only Egypt and Persia, who inscribed their history upon stones, upon walls and upon pyramids, but even the mos uncivilized people have also understood the significance of history. In Africa and America there are a great number of savage tribes, yellow and brown, who still roam about naked and wear for ornaments brass rings in their noses, turtle-shells in their lips, lead bracelets on their ankles, horns or feathers on their

heads; their naked bodies are tattooed and decorated with many-colored figures. And even these savages, who still worship sticks and stones, appreciate the importance of history! And because the men are perpetually occupied with ceaseless warfare and with their only means of livelihood—fishing or hunting—they make it the duty of the women to preserve by tradition everything that has happened to the tribe in all the generations, and be able to recount it at every proper occasion."

"Perhaps, then, it is really a minhag akum, a heathen practice?"

“Which simply shows that you do not even know the Bible and our other sacred literature. The Pentateuch commences with Genesis; it tells all the history of the Jews up to the time of the death of Moses; then came the early prophets, Chronicles, the later prophets; in the Talmud there are treasures of history. Even more, Moses, our teacher, inscribed the Law upon a stone before all Israel. History you will find in the liturgy, in all our penitential prayers and sacred poetry, in all our books; only, one should know how to seek for it. One should know how, and one must seek! One must have the whole ‘cone of sugar’ in one’s head and heart and blood; and if only a few generations are missing from the middle, then the apex crumbles away and the last generations fall apart and lose themselves among kingdoms, oceans and deserts. We have no territory to unite us; upon our boundaries there stand no armed men, no cannon and no army to protect us. Our unity—whether or no we are to be proud of it—is founded on an ideal; it is in the heart and in the brain! and do you think that such a unity can exist without history?”

* * *

Iron, it occured to me, should be forged while it is hot; it is not always you get the respectful attention of a fellow Jew. Therefore I do not let him go, but continue as follows: