prophet of that Mission, Moses Mendelssohn, who had first raised into prominence the idea of a Mission of Israel. Yet his own children had become converted to Christianity. Those who believed, therefore, that Jews should be content to live in dispersion, to subserve a vague and nebulous Mission of Israel, were contributing to the gradual disruption of Jewry. A further misrepresentation of which Mr. Magnus had been guilty was in trying to make theme believe that Mr. Zangwill and his scheme of a settlement in Mesopotamia dominated the present situation in the Zionist Movement. Surely Mr. Magnus ought to be well aware of the fact that Mr. Zangwill had left the Zionist Movement four years ago and had founded an organization of his own. If Mr. Magnus was not aware of that fact, then his ignorance was inexcusable. If he was aware of it, then his suppression of it was worse than inexcusable.
Mr. Cohen said Mr. Magnus had asked them to think imperially about Jewish questions, and yet he had advocated the claims of the Jewish Board of Guardians in London, a purely local body, as superior to those of the Zionist movement, which had for its aim the permanent advancement of the collective welfare of universal Jewry. But the most serious inconsistency of all, which entirely vitiated the discourse to which they had listened that evening and which minimized its value from the intellectual point of view, was that which related to Mr. Magnus's conception of Zion. First, he had told them that the Zion for which he had dreamed and longed and prayed was not the Zion which the Zionists were endeavoring to bring about by practical and political means. And yet he had gone on to utter a prolonged lamentation because, as he said, the fulfilment of the Zionist scheme would deprive him of his prayers and rob him of his ideal. If Mr. Mag-
nus believed that the Zion for which he had been so ardently longing would be realized by present-day Zionists, how could he say that his Zion was different from political Zionism? His particular Zion, he had told them, had no fixed geographical center, and its fulfilment was not to be expected in our day. But the Zion of the Zionists was a fixed geographical center—Palestine, and Mr. Magnus's expectation that its attainment would rob him of his prayers evidently implied a belief that Zionism would be realized in our day. It was therefore evident that Mr. Magnus was not quite clear what his particular species of Zionism was, and what particular Zion he was dreaming of and praying for. Surely Mr. Magnus should have rejoiced and not lamented in anticipation of that glorious time. But he had lamented because he feared that Zion realized would deprive him of his prayers. If the achievement of Zionism would have such an effect, then it would, indeed, be a most alarming prospect. But Mr. Magnus could take comfort to his soul. As a matter of fact, the Reformers in Germany and America had long ago expunged from their prayer-book all references to the restoration of Zion, and yet they had managed to save a sufficient quantity of prayers to justify the maintenance of numberless grandiose temples. So that even if the Zionist scheme were fulfilled in the days of Mr. Magnus, and even if the Zion of the political Zionists correspond to the Zion of Mr. Magnus's dreams—a puzzle he would not attempt to solve—there would still be quite enough prayers in the Hebrew Prayer-book to satisfy the soul of their lecturer. But if the Zion of the Zionists did not correspond to Mr. Magnus's dreams, then he could surely continue his prayers for the coming of the Messiah, for after the adherents of Zionism had done their utmost there would still be a great deal left which could only be accomplished.....
