colony. I submit this as my own experience, as the fate to which I shall succumb, if (as seems always most improbable) the Zionists achieve concrete success. But I think you may multiply me by thousands. I think there are thousands like me, whose Judaism will be reduced to nothingness if the easy argument of these self-styled statesmen is satisfied, and the Jews remaining in Europe and America are confronted with a so-called Zion state, depriving them for ever of the right of praying for the restoration to Zion. These Zionists repeat in an intensified degree the mistake which some of us think we see in parts of the legislation of the present government. In their relief of distress, they tend to the destruction of virtue. In their unimaginative, sentimental regard for local suffering and distress, they neglect the forces which form character, and the moral bases of right action. They seek to relieve a single section of the commonwealth without regard to the rights of other classes. Without pressing this analogy too far, for I am unwilling to spoil a good case by introducing a political parallel, however close it may seem to me, the danger in this Jewish problem seems to me indisputable. I regard the use of the name of Zion, however "safe" a "percentage" it may pay, as a betrayal, in this context, of the hope for which educated Jews maintain their allegiance to their faith.
To my mind, a Judaism divorced from its historical aspects is not Judaism at all. Ours is certainly a spiritual religion: Judaism in some of its tenets is the most spiritual form of faith ever conceived. But it is bound by indissoluble links to the past and therefore to the future. Its mission —the Zion at which it aims—imposes an obligation on its followers to maintain their connection with Jews in all the places of their dispersion, and not locally to assimilate themselves with the
people among whom they dwell, by adapting their forms and ceremonies to a strictly western type, or by dropping their religious separateness, whether of Sabbath or of speech. The past and the future alike, forbid this specious surrender to a hypersensitive Occidental consciousness. Yet, what is to prevent such a surrender, what sound argument can be advanced to oppose it, if Zion is established in our day. To-day, we can say to the Jewish Religious Union, as I have said for several years past: "You are obstructing the mission of Israel, you are retarding the advent of Zion, and obscuring the unity of the Jews." To-day this appeal avails to keep within the Jewish fold large numbers of educated Jews—the neglected classes of my analogy above—who deem their adhesion worth while for the sake of the mission of the race, who believe that there is a future for Judaism transcending the temporary inconvenience of allegiance to at least a qualifying portion of its historical forms. To-morrow, if the Zionists had their way, this appeal would be vain. "Zion is established," these would say; "there is no future to look forward to, and the past, therefore, loses its obligation. Our forefathers followed a false hope. They suffered and died in a vain cause. It was not the perfection of mankind, not the reign of God's law on earth, not the conversion of the world to the Hebrew ideal of monotheism, to Hebrew priciples of conduct, and to the standard of Hebraism in affairs, to which our prophetical writings point, and for which our ancestors have wrought, and by which we are content to be bound, however tempting apostasy may be, not these, not the Zion of our ideal, but your Zion in Mesopotamia was the end, and now Judaism is played out; it is a spent force among the moral forces which make for progress; there is nothing left to keep me a Jew."