ception to Jewish idealism, which I, for one, deeply deplore. As long as Zion is before me, not a Hebrew colony in Mesopotamia, but the Zion of Isaiah and his disciples—“for ye shall not .go out with haste, nor go by flight”—as long as the symbolic Zion of Israel’s mission is before me, I see an object in my exile, and, as clearly as human sight permits, I see the purpose which consecrates the tragic history of my race. The tragedy may evoke our tears, it may more worthily evoke our noblest efforts to relieve it; at times and in places it may seem too harsh for mortal endurance. But at least there is an end in view.
For a Zionist in the older sense—the only true sense as I conceive it—at least there is something to hope for, something to aim at, something to unify the diverse spectacle of trial. The tragedy is maintained at tragic height. It does not sink into a melodrama of aimless, purposeless suffering, or patience stretched on the rack, for the mere measure of endurance. Rob Israel of Zion, bring Zion again in our day, realize the ideal as effectively even as Dr. Herzl desired, and you destroy the raison d'etre of our persistence, you render nugatory all that we have won, you deflower Judaism of its essence, and make the nome of Jew an empty boast.
Mr. Zangwill told us the other day: “The Ito has not the least belief that the Jews who are free citizens of the British Empire, America, France, Germany, or Italy, would ever, except in a small percentage of cases, leave these lands of comparative happiness for the discomforts of a raw country......We speak only of those who cannot or will not remain in the lands in which they at present live. We bring no unsettlement to those whose roots are planted where they are. But to those who are moving of themselves, we say, do not make the mistake of going to another country where your people will be under the same conditions as in the country you are leaving.” And Dr. Daickes, in an address which he delivered before the London University Zionist So-
ciety on May 23d, declared, in so many words: "It is not the intention of Zionism that all the Jews all over the world should leave the countries in which they live and emigrate to Palestine. This is not necessary, this is scarcely possible.. What we want is to create a center of Jewish culture, a new spring of Jewish ideas. What we want is a new creative Israel in the land of Israel. But a great number of Jews will always remain in the Diaspora and continue to be citizens in the lands in which they live."
I confess that these sentiments, and sentiments like them, so lightly uttered in accordance with the expediency of the plan which is at the moment being recommended, fill me with amazement as a Jew. These men are going to found their Zion, they are going to claim the fulfilment of the Zionistic aspirations of their race, and what, we may ask, are they going to leave for the comfort, the aspiration and the sustenance of those who do not follow them to Mesopotamia? I, for one, am not going to Mesopotamia, and hitherto I have cared for Zion. Supposing—a big supposition—but supposing this colony were started. Supposing Zion a fact, a somewhat insignificant fact, but still no longer an ideal of the Jew, trained by his own prophets. What is there left for me to pray for? Why should I bring my children up as Jews? The Restoration will be, ex hypothesi, accomplished. The mission of Israel will be accomplished—inadequately, I may think, and ironically and falsely to the martyrs who died for it, but accomplished and realized nevertheless, I may pray for the prosperity of the new Jerusalem in Asia. I may invoke a conventional blessing on Mesopotamic Zion among other States, friendly to King Edward, but, as a Zionist, I have nothing to look forward to; as a Jew, I see nothing to justify the continued suffering and ambition of my race.
The Zionists have destroyed my Zion. My dream, my prophetic dream, of Messianic fulfilment will be mocked by the Zionist flag of those who migrate to that