The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 5 · November 1909
177printed page
scan 27 of 52
Facsimile · scan 27 of 52
Scan of p. 177
Text · transcribed from the scan

life in Palestine. It is a story of growth in a normal manner. He tells of dwellings erected in Jaffa; factories in Haifa; railroad concessions; water works concessions in Jerusalem; the branching out of the Anglo-Palestine company; details of the life of the Jews in the colonies; accessions of vigorous working forces in the population;—all contributing to the development of the picture which every Zionist dreams of as a completed thing.

It is a pity that he is not able to tell us of abler direction by far-seeing Zionist leaders; whatever is attained now in Zion is individual attainment. He sees little being done by the central organization, which we all hope shall some day move into Zion as the de facto government, when conditions are ripe for it. He sees a lack of imagination on the part of our leaders, a willingness to let conditions thrust opportunities upon them, rather than a desire to go out and seek opportunities. There is little of national planning and direction. The minor channels of influence and power are being passed by.

It is to be hoped that the next Congress will place in control of the movement a body of men able, far-seeing, above partisanship, whose time will be devoted to the business of Zionism on a national basis.

THE MCCLURE ARTICLE.

WITH the truth of the Turner article, which appeared in McClure's magazine last month, THE MACCABAEAN does not wish to deal. The amount of error in fact committed by the author of the article cannot adequately be gone into here. That the vice of prostitution prevails in the city of New York is generally admitted; that it owes a great deal of its criminal features to political corruption and protection, is common knowledge. That history of prostitution dates back to Egypt, and not a century of civilization, not a nation, Christian or pagan, was ever free from this destructive evil. To have discovered a state of affairs like this in a city like New

York is not a remarkable feat of journalistic enterprise.

That the evil of prostitution does not involve only women, is another patent fact; and that the social outcasts have abettors who in some cases protect them and in some cases exploit them, is also a fact which may be established by the slightest sort of an investigation.

The Turner article, however, not only made it appear that the business of exploiting women and entangling them in a life of shame prevailed in the United States, but also that Jews were the leading malefactors. The truth of this assertion has been properly challenged and the writer of the article has been properly stigmatized as a provoker of race prejudice. The inference that he is an anti-Semite may be drawn from the fact that the article in question was not written in the regular line of duty and published as a serious contribution to a study of civic conditions, but was planned, written, and published primarily to influence the municipal election in New York. The use of the facts, gossip, inferences, exaggerated by the liberal use of adjectives, whatever they may be, in a sensational magazine offered for sale to one of the interested parties and then projected into a campaign is sufficient evidence of the motive actuating the writer. In making political capital for his party, he did not care whose reputation suffered, least of all the reputation of the Jewish people.

That the Jews have their share of poverty is admitted; that the golus creates havoc with their settled habits and produces all sorts of awkward complications, is admitted; but that the Jews are cursed, in addition to all their other troubles, with an undue share of the white slave traffic, we do not hesitate for one moment to deny. It is, moreover, shameful, that in a crisis involving the honor of the Jewish race, threatened by misleading unsubstantiated sensational newspaper indictments, a number of our prominent Jewish leaders should have considered the victory of their political party of more