The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 5 · November 1909
173printed page
scan 23 of 52

So-and-so and give him Koved, since he was a heavy contributor to the congregational treasury and deserved Koved.

Now, this vicious system of "giving Koved" is also one of the causes undermining the dignity of the Rabbinate.

Next, I might mention the still more vicious system of giving and accepting "fees." Some congregations pay their rabbi barely a living salary in the hope that he will be amply compensated by fees of one sort or another. How can the dignity and the sacredness of the rabbinical office be maintained under such circumstances? The man whom I honor, I cannot give a fee to.

not give a fee to.But the real cause lies much deeper. Itlies in the fact that Reform in Judaismcame not from within and below, fromthe masses of the Jewish people, but fromwithout and above, from the privilegedfew that were attracted by the glamourof their Christian surroundings. The result is that the people have never reallyand intimately adjusted themselves to thenew ideas and practices imposed uponthem from without. Whatever adjustments were made, were too abrupt, tooartificial, to become ingrained in the soulof the people. For this reason, Jews havenot yet been able to look upon preachingin the same light as Christians. To Christians, who for centuries have been trained to listen to, and appreciate sermons,preaching is a vital necessity of their religious life. With Jews, however, thisis different. Our training in listening to(and with due respect to my colleagues:in preaching) sermons is of comparativelyrecent date; for the old-time Jewish rabbi, while he did preach at rare intervals,was not a preacher in the modern sense.Consequently, Jews regard preaching as asource of entertainment rather than ofreligious edification, and the preacher asan entertainer rather than as a mouthpieceof the Word. Preaching, with Jews, is aluxury, not a necessity; hence, the lackof deference shown by the laity in theirtreatment of the rabbi.

The most potent cause, however, still

must be mentioned. It is inherent in the very nature of the rabbinical office as seen in the light of history. The rabbinate in earlier times was pre-eminently an aristocratic office. The rabbi was the undisputed head of the congregation, provided with full disciplinary powers, whom everybody respected and honored, as a matter of course. Once elected, his was a life-tenure. In many cases, the office became hereditary. It is obvious that the aristocratic character of the rabbinate could not be upheld in modern times, in a democratic society. It is also obvious, that the task of adjusting an essentially aristocratic office to modern democratic social conditions is an extremely difficult one. One of the necessary results of the Reform movement was the democraticization of the rabbinate. Since, however, the Reform movement provided for a faulty adjustment, the change of the character of the rabbinical office proved baneful to the standing of the rabbi. By a sudden swing of the pendulum the rabbinate was deprived of all authority and dignity, the laity assuming a supremacy lacking in dignity. For centuries the laity had been prostrate at the feet of the rabbinate; today the rabbinate is expected to prostrate itself at the feet of the laity. There is a historical feud between the Talmud Chacham and the Am-Ha-aretz. Our age (in America) is the age of the Am-Ha-aretz!

Proper adjustment would have eliminated grovelling on both sides, but would have spared the prestige, the lustre of the rabbinical office which it enjoyed from of old. There will be, of course, those who will be ready to deny that this lustre has diminished. And from the viewpoint of the sacred guild-spirit, any such denials will be welcome. But that will make very little difference to lovers of plain talk.

Wherein lies the remedy of the above evils? As soon as the Jewish masses will take their religious affairs into their own hands, as soon as they will consent to do their own reform work, and make such