The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 4 · October 1909
1scan
of 52

THE MACCABAEAN

THE LESSON OF THE RECENT KIEFF CANARD

A few days after Rosh Hashonah a circumstantial report of a pogrom in Kieff, Russia, was circulated in the press of this country, as well as of England and Germany. The report appeared on its surface to be authentic—the details were so so graphic.

At once, from every Jewish center effort was made to substantiate the account, and within forty-eight hours it was established with a great deal of certainty that no pogrom had taken place in Kieff, and that the entire story was based on an insignificant occurrence in a village near Kieff, which justified no such extraordinary journalistic stretch of imagination.

The Jewish world was naturally very much alarmed in the meantime; cablegrams flew right and left; statements were issued by prominent organizations and individuals; and the Hon. Simon Wolf, of Washington, D. C., went through his habitual performance of applying to the state department for information.

Notwithstanding the years that have elapsed since the days of Kishineff, there seems to have been no progress in the direction of better international organization of the Jewish people.

The same chaos reigns; the same hurry-scurry, makeshift, short-sighted policy, which found us when the Kishineff outbreak occurred, able only to forward money to the sufferers. ' Among those who control the destinies of Jewish philanthropy and high politics, very little has been learned since the terrible days when Russia made a holyday of Jewish misery.

The Kishineff incident closed with the general conclusion that the Jewish problem in Russia must be solved in Russia, but steps were at once taken for the further scattering of the Russian Jews.

The Galveston extravaganza is one sequel to Kishineff; and all the activity of the Ito in emigration work is another.

But, as in all things Jewish, the expressed theory did not harmonize with the actual feeling of those who expressed them. While the problem in Russia was an internal one, and could not be settled by emigration, it was the prevalent feeling that something must be done to relieve the pressure of Jewish population in Russia; but instead of rallying about one center, where the strength of the Jewish people could be concentrated, the powers-that-be continued the old Goluth policy of scattering the Jews, to Canada, to Texas, to Argentine, but never in the direction of the one place where Jewish life could be normalized.

Let another pogrom break out in Russia, and we shall once more face an anarchistic Jewish public opinion. The first aid to the injured will be proposed, and Jewish humanitarian sentiment will provide the means; and as soon as the clamor subsides, again we shall hear the counsel of the temporizer, the half-thinking, the timid, and the opportunist; and unless Zionist thought and philosophy have permeated the Jewish people and more especially, the leaders in Jewish affairs, the same national disgrace will be repeated, and the same policy will dispose of another crisis in Jewish life.