We have then our opposing types, Reform Judaism and Zionism. Which shall we, here in America, adopt? No greater misfortune could befall us than to become like our Reform Jew type. It has been well said that in him the curse of the one hundred and thirty-seventh psalm has been fulfilled. For he has forgotten Jerusalem and he has not remembered Zion, and truly has his right hand lost her cunning and has his tongue cloven to the roof of his mouth. If this is not credited, go into our schools and observe the stupidity of the second generation of Jews, stupidity surpising even the Gentile instructors, who once believed that all Jewish children were geniuses; go into our social gatherings and observe the card-playing and idle gossip that have taken the place of the intellectual discussions of an older time; go into our "temples" and observe the porcine unspirituality of the men there, the silly vanity of the women, the prematurity and overdressed impertinence of the children. The Reform sect, to be sure, justifies its existence by claiming a mission to the nations, a mission to be performed only in exile among the nations. But what great man has Reform Judaism given the world? What doctrine has it dessiminated for the welfare of humanity? What creed of social betterment does it stand for that is its own? To
fulfill a mission with nothing to missionize about; to declare a function of indoctrination and to have no doctrines: is the sap of life here? But what possible new ideals can Reform Judaism create, even supposing the good will? Crushed by a hostile environment, constantly losing its adherents, devoted to the interests of materialistic congregations, intent only on imitating their neighbors, not daring to go beyond a milk-and-water creed that shall offend no one, though it attract no one, what has Reform Judaism done for us or what can it do for us? Will anyone die for the principles of Reform Judaism? Does anyone trust his life to them, or remember them in the day of evil? Do they inspire spirituality, untainted morality, sainthood, asceticism, plain living and high thinking, or any of the effects, in short, of a true religion? Or does Reform Judaism not rather wander off into bypaths of maudlin "sociology" or into mazes of some quackery like Christian Science? Today, realizing its own futility, it seeks a new dogma, and it has found it, negatively as always, in its opposition to Zionism. For Zionism will do and is doing all that Reform Judaism has failed to do; and best of all, in it has been found that unifying principle which brings together in harmony, all the diversified sects in Jewry. There is no race prejudice in Zion.