on the name of Zion; they have sworn to remember Jerusalem; their hope and longing in thought and prayer have centered in Palestine. But century after century of deprival has at last weaned them; weaned them unconsciously, so that they have gone on repeating mechanically the formula of a return to Zion. Now, when the call comes to put an empty prayer into force, when the opportunity is offered to make a wish: a reality, then the Jew suddenly awakens to the fact that he does not mean what he prays, that he does not feel what he wishes. Even as the convict who has been confined many years in a prison cell is unable to enjoy freedom when the jail doors are unlocked before him—blinks at the bright sunlight, is uneasy in the open air and under the blue sky, longs for the dark room and the regularity of prison routine, so the Jew finds that exile has grown into a pleasant habit, that Golus is a comfortable state, that the fleshpots of Egypt are not altogether undesirable. The Jews today regard with repugnance any new Exodus; like Tennyson's slothful lotus-eaters, their one demand is "Let us alone!"
Here, then, is the first difficulty that baffled and disheartened Herzl; but there is another, rising out of the first, that is just as great. This is the sectionalism of the Jews, the fact that their exile lies among many nationalities and races, whose prejudices and qualities they are bound to absorb and reproduce. Even before the dispersal of the Jew, merchant and trader like his kinsman, the Phœnician, he had wandered to many different lands, wherein he was left, at the destruction of the second Temple, a man without a country. The dispersal of the Palestinian Jews after that event, sent them helter-skelter over the earth, into the Mediterranean countries and Africa, up into Germany and Poland, over into France and even into China. In those days and in the Middle Ages, the Jews, unemancipated, still resembled each other closely in the celebration of like religious festivals in the same way, in the similar phraseology of prayers, in the restriction to limited occupations, in the gen-
eral fact of persecution. But gradually, in the course of years, Jews in different countries became different. And today, when Zionism is stirring the sensibilities of Jews so as to vivify the desire for a return to Palestine, how diversified a sectional problem meets us! American Jew, German Jew, Russian Jew—how shall we reconcile them, now that more than ever each has taken on the color of his environment? And how shall we bring into the camp of Zionism the minor sections? Truly, how shall we?—to work against the inertia and indifference of twenty centuries, split up and diversified by the prejudices of a score of nationalisms! The problem of sectionalism stands like a rock in the road. Yet, to be solved, the problem must be understood; and I shall therefore examine in more exact detail, the results upon the Jews of their dispersal in so many different lands.
II.
The first fact we notice in our consideration of the Jews in their various environments is that today they live in different stages of emancipation according to the land of their sojourn. The Jew ot tke English-speaking world is perhaps in enjoyment of most advantages; the Jews in France, Germany, Austria, Italy, Scandinavia and Turkey of scarcely less; of the Jews in Russia, Roumania and Morocco I need not speak. Now, what is the effect of their various stages of freedom on the feelings of the Jews towards each other? The effect may be summed up briefly: the different sections of Jews, when brought into actual contact, have either hatred or contempt for each other. Nor is the explanation of this fact long in finding, nor altogether unnatural or unparalleled, when found. For the greatest wrong wrought by tyranny and oppression is that under them the souls of the tryannized and oppressed are warped to hate their fellow-slaves; and that a race which has been partly emancipated is rent and torn by a cruel psychical fratricide. For there is ever present the fear in that small minority which has been granted privileges by
