The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 3 · September 1909
100printed page
scan 14 of 52

the hatred and ostracism of their Gentile surroundings? With money you may buy a palace in an exclusive neighborhood, you may bedeck your person with expensive garments and luxurious gems, you may become a patron of the sciences and the arts, and even imitate to perfection the manners and customs of your aristocratic neighbors. Yet your gold will not help you in the least to obtain a welcome place among them, once your origin is known. And for this reason I believe that the immigrant Jew is much more to be commended for his willing and wilful adherence to his own, than they who would run away from themselves. The former recognizes his social limitations and is content to abide by his lot; where the latter by his insistence on social prestige, only makes himself despicable by continuing to live a life of sham. I repeat, that in the midst of all his luxury and wealth the display of which only serves to incite the envy of his unfriendly neighbors— the rich Jew is most cowardly in his marrano-existence. He is always in fear of being detected and proclaimed as a Jew, and his life is ever that of a moral Ghetto.

“As for America where you have stated, this problem does not exist to such a serious extent as it does in Europe—the future alone will tell. The history of the Jews in your country is still in its incipiency. From what I have heard and read, I know that anti-Semitism is not lagging behind in the United States. America is not the ‘melting pot’ of races, as Mr. Zangwill would have it. One cannot so easily eradicate traditions that are deep-seated and centuries old. . Do not the Germans or the Irish in your country still form a homogeneous mass, a class apart by temperament and political ambition? The Jew, too, will always continue to form in your country a race apart from the other elements. Temperamentally, the Jews are a clannish race. The religion of the Jews, too, serves to prevent the complete amalgam between himself and his Gentile neighbors, for Judaism is more

or less of a tribal and nationalistic faith. Once a Jew, always a Jew.

“And you really believe, then, that the only satisfactory colution of the Jewish problem is a return to Palestine?” I ventured to ask.

“Most certainly. Palestine is the only land which will forever appeal to our people, owing to its many historic associations. What we need is a large influx of our brethren there. Under the new and benign regime of the Young Turks, it does not seem at all improbable that our movement will ultimately be crowned with success.

"Do not tell me, as so many others have done, that Palestine is a land unfit for large commercial or agricultural operations, or that, at the very best, it could support only a very small number of our people. All difficulties will be removed when the pioneer spirit has once taken a hold of our people. It is this spirit that we, Zionists, are now seeking to foster. As for the smallness of the territory—it has never been considered by us a serious obstacle. You are well aware that the past greatness of the Jewish race was never dependent on numbers. Neither will be its future. It is not necessary that all Jews should go back to Palestine. We will not, as we cannot, force anyone to go. What we want is substantial human material from among our suffering brethren wherewith to build up a state that shall be Jewish in spiritual endeavor as well as in economic interest. We want to make the new Jewish state in Palestine the one great center that shall reflect glory upon all of our dispersed brethren.”

“And what about the Jews who cannot emigrate to Palestine?” was the question asked him. “Do you really believe that they are doomed to moral and spiritual extinction as far as our Jewish race is concerned, owing to their unenviable surroundings? Do you not deem it advisable, as Achad Haam has been advocating for many years, that centers for the upbuilding of a Jewish racial culture should first be established in the different lands where the Jews are settled, before there